Protecting you from the unexpected and planning for the predictable
Sheeley Insurance Agency is a locally owned and operated insurance agency with a rich history dating back to 1933. At Sheeley Insurance Agency, we specialize in providing personalized insurance solutions for individuals and businesses throughout Pennsylvania. We are committed to delivering top-notch service, expert advice, and unparalleled coverage options to our valued clients.
Our Mission
Our mission is to provide exceptional insurance products and unparalleled service to our clients, while building long-term relationships based on trust, integrity, and personal attention. We strive to be proactive partners in our clients' insurance journey, advising and guiding them through the complexities of insurance to ensure that they are adequately protected and prepared for the unexpected.
Our Services
Our professionals at Sheeley Insurance Agency offer a wide range of insurance solutions, including:
- Personal Insurance: We provide customized coverage options for homeowners, auto owners, motorcycle riders, condo owners, and flood victims.
- Business Insurance: Our expert advisors help businesses like yours navigate the complexities of insurance, offering solutions for business owners, commercial liability, property, and auto insurance.
- Day Care Center Insurance: We specialize in providing comprehensive insurance solutions for day care centers, including liability insurance, business personal property coverage, workers' compensation, cyber liability, umbrella/excess liability, professional liability, and abuse/molestation coverage.
- Specialized Business Insurance: We offer tailored insurance solutions for various industries, including businesses that require commercial auto insurance coverage.
Our Commitment
As a Keystone Insurers Group Partner, we have the resources of over 50 insurance companies at our disposal, enabling us to provide our clients with the best insurance solutions at the best possible prices. Our dedication to exceptional service, expert advice, and personal attention sets us apart from other insurance agencies. We believe that each of our clients deserves the utmost dedication, expert advice, and personal attention from a trusted partner.
Get a Quote
At Sheeley Insurance Agency, we are committed to providing personalized insurance solutions that meet the unique needs of our clients. To learn more about our insurance products and services, please do not hesitate to contact us. We look forward to serving you.
Positive Reviews
The majority of the reviews for Sheeley Insurance are extremely positive, with a consistent theme of excellent customer service, responsiveness, and professionalism. Reviewers praise the agency's quick response times, knowledge, and willingness to go above and beyond to meet their needs.
Negative Reviews
One reviewer, Philip Pritchard, gave a 4-star review, mentioning that John was responsive in helping renegotiate their house insurance and save them money, but didn't provide any specific criticisms.

Be the first to review Sheeley Insurance Agency.
Write a Review