Serving Lake City Since 1969
The Wheeler Agency, a family-owned and operated business, has been a pillar of the Lake City community since 1969. Founded by Priscilla Wheeler, the agency has maintained a steadfast commitment to personal service for families and businesses for over 50 years. Our office, originally located above the Rexall Drug store in downtown Lake City, has evolved over the years, but our dedication to providing warm, friendly, and knowledgeable service has remained the same.
Our Team
John Wheeler, the current owner and licensed agent, joined the family business in 1999 after teaching special education for several years. He is an active member of the Rotary Club of Lake City, Chamber of Commerce, Boy Scouts Troop 85, and Hopeful Baptist Church. Melissa Harden, a Personal Lines Agent, has been with the agency for many years, specializing in auto, home, boat, RV, and motorcycle insurance. She is a Disney fanatic, a proud mother of four, and a loving grandmother of eight. Hannah Beth Wood, our Commercial Lines Customer Service Representative, specializes in Workers' Compensation and Payroll Services. Hannah is an enthusiastic gardener, a dog mama, and has embarked on the adventure of visiting all 50 states.
Our Services
At The Wheeler Agency, we are dedicated to providing our clients with the best coverage to suit their needs. We offer an extensive range of services:
- Auto Insurance: We understand the importance of protecting your vehicle, and we work diligently to customize the right policy for you.
- Homeowners Insurance: Our team is experienced in providing information and options to ensure your home is fully protected.
- Business Insurance: We help businesses of all sizes protect their investments with commercial insurance tailored to their needs.
- Boat, Motorcycle, and RV Insurance: Our services extend beyond the typical expectations, ensuring that your leisure vehicles are covered.
- Life and Health Insurance: We provide a variety of life and health insurance policies that cater to your specific financial and personal needs, including life, health, and disability insurance.
- Other Services: The Wheeler Agency offers several additional services, including flood, umbrella liability, and builders' risk insurance.
Why Choose Us
As an independent agency, The Wheeler Agency can offer a diverse range of options from multiple insurance companies. This means we can find the right coverage at a competitive price for our clients. We are proud of our long-standing reputation and believe in the power of building relationships, trust, and integrity with our clients.
Overall Experience
The Wheeler Agency has received predominantly positive reviews, with customers praising the agency's professionalism, knowledge, and courtesy. Many reviewers have expressed their appreciation for the agency's helpfulness, responsiveness, and commitment to finding the best policies for their needs.
Positive Aspects
- Knowledgeable and Professional Staff: Reviewers have praised the agency's staff for their knowledge and professionalism, with several mentioning specific agents who went above and beyond to help them.
- Excellent Customer Service: Customers have appreciated the agency's courteous and helpful service, with many feeling valued and treated like family.
- Responsive and Helpful: The agency has been commended for its responsiveness and willingness to help customers with their insurance needs.
Negative Aspects
- Denial of Claims: One reviewer had a negative experience with the agency, citing that they denied their claim and used legal technicalities to justify the denial.

Be the first to review Wheeler Agency.
Write a Review