Call Now
Website
Call
Business Details
50+ Years
experience
Your Trusted Partner for Insurance Solutions in West Michigan
Nulty Insurance has been a trusted independent insurance agency serving West Michigan since 1945. Founded in Otsego by Greg Nulty, the company began with a focus on farm and personal insurance, evolving over generations to offer comprehensive personal, business, and employee benefits solutions. With offices in Kalamazoo, St. Joseph, Iron Mountain, and Grand Rapids, Nulty Insurance combines personalized service with access to top-rated national and regional carriers. Our team of licensed advisors prioritizes client needs, offering tailored coverage through auto, home, life, health, and commercial policies.

We emphasize transparency, no hidden fees, and ongoing policy reviews to ensure lifelong protection. Recognized as one of Michigan's 101 Best and Brightest Companies, we pride ourselves on community involvement and innovative risk management. Our partnerships with Keystone Insurers Group and UBA further enhance our ability to deliver exceptional value and service.
Services
Auto Insurance Home Insurance Business Insurance Employee Benefits Life Insurance
Details
  • Year established: 1945
Highlights and features
  • We offer over 80 years of local insurance expertise since 1945
  • Our team provides personalized coverage reviews throughout your lifetime
  • We partner with top-rated national and regional insurance carriers
  • Our advisors hold professional designations in multiple insurance specialties
  • We provide 24/7 client portal access for policy management
What people say
Incredible service Premium unbeatable Excellent customer service Top-notch support Easiest open enrollment
Services
Auto Insurance
Auto insurance protects your vehicle investment against accidents, theft, and weather-related damage. We offer liability coverage, collision protection, and comprehensive policies tailored to Michigan's requirements. Our advisors help clients understand coverage options including bodily injury liability, property damage, and uninsured motorist protection while ensuring adequate limits for asset protection.
Home Insurance
Home insurance safeguards your primary residence against fire, water damage, and liability claims. Policies include replacement cost coverage, personal property protection, and additional living expense provisions. We specialize in customized solutions for primary homes, secondary properties, and unique collections requiring scheduled coverage.
Business Insurance
Business insurance protects commercial operations through workers' compensation, general liability, and property policies. Our solutions include cyber liability protection, business interruption coverage, and specialized programs for industry-specific risks. We serve Michigan businesses with tailored risk management strategies and claims support.
Employee Benefits
Employee benefits packages include health, dental, and vision insurance alongside disability and life coverage. We assist employers with plan design, compliance, and enrollment processes. Our team provides ongoing support for open enrollment periods and mid-year changes to maintain competitive benefit offerings.
Life Insurance
Life insurance ensures financial protection for dependents through term, whole, and universal life policies. We help clients determine appropriate coverage amounts for mortgage protection, income replacement, and business continuity. Our advisors explain policy features including cash value accumulation and premium flexibility options.
People
TG Nulty
Chief Executive Officer & President
Third-generation leader with over 30 years in insurance, specializing in strategic growth and agency operations. Holds multiple industry certifications and maintains active involvement in community development initiatives.
Tom Jager
Vice President of Commercial Lines
Commercial insurance expert with 25+ years experience in risk management solutions for Michigan businesses. Specializes in construction, manufacturing, and professional services sectors while maintaining multiple industry designations.
Susan Culhane
Vice President of Employee Benefits
HR and benefits specialist with two decades of experience in designing competitive workplace benefits packages. Recognized for simplifying complex insurance concepts for clients across various industries.
Bill Shearer
Personal Insurance Advisor
Personal lines specialist with 15 years of experience in homeowners and auto insurance. Focuses on creating customized protection plans while maintaining high client retention through proactive policy reviews.
Chad Bonner
P&C Operations Director
Property and casualty operations leader with expertise in claims management and underwriting processes. Implements technology solutions to improve client service efficiency across multiple insurance lines.
Questions
What types of insurance does Nulty Insurance offer?
We provide personal insurance (auto, home, life), business insurance (workers' comp, liability, cyber), and employee benefits (health, dental, vision) across West Michigan.
How can I get a personalized insurance quote?
Contact our Kalamazoo office at 269-372-9200 or complete our online quote request form to connect with a licensed advisor for tailored coverage options.
Do you offer 24/7 claims support?
While we maintain regular business hours, our client portal provides 24/7 access for claims reporting and policy management resources.
Are you affiliated with any insurance networks?
We partner with Keystone Insurers Group and UBA to access preferred carrier networks while maintaining independent agency status for client choice.
How do you help with policy reviews?
Our advisors conduct annual policy reviews to ensure coverage adapts to life changes, business growth, and evolving risk exposures across all insurance lines.
What areas do you serve?
We primarily serve West Michigan with offices in Kalamazoo, St. Joseph, Iron Mountain, and Grand Rapids, providing coverage across residential and commercial sectors.