Your Independent Ohio Insurance Agents
At McCutcheon Insurance Agency, Inc., we pride ourselves on being an independent Ohio insurance agency with a rich history dating back to 1947. Founded in Cuyahoga Falls, Ohio, our agency has evolved over the years to provide comprehensive insurance options to both personal and commercial clients across all of Ohio, including Akron, Cleveland, Columbus, Cincinnati, Dayton, and Toledo.
Our History
Our agency was founded by a second-generation independent insurance agent, Jenny Pillen, who is a graduate of Bowling Green State University with a degree in Business. With more than 35 years of commercial, personal, and surety experience, Jenny has led our agency to become one of the most respected and trusted insurance agencies in Ohio.
Meet Our Team
We are comprised of experienced and certified insurance professionals, including our co-owners, Jenny Pillen and Jennifer Keim, both Certified Insurance Counselors (CIC). Our team is dedicated to providing personalized service and expert guidance to our clients, helping them navigate the complexities of the insurance world.
Our Services
At McCutcheon Insurance Agency, we offer a wide range of insurance services, including:
Auto Insurance
As Ohio auto insurance specialists, we shop various auto insurance partners to find the best combination of price and coverage available in the state. Our team will work with you to design a policy that meets your specific needs, providing liability protection, collision coverage, medical payments, towing, and labor and roadside assistance.
Homeowners Insurance
We understand the importance of protecting your home, apartment, or condo. Our homeowners insurance policy covers your property, providing financial protection in the event of a covered loss. We can help you understand the difference between your home and property's "cash value" versus its "replacement value" so that you're properly insured at the most competitive price.
Business Insurance
By fully reviewing the commercial requirements of your Ohio-based business, we help you understand the exposed risks of your business and then create a plan to help manage those risks. Our business insurance policies provide coverage for property, liability, workers' compensation, and more.
Motorcycle Insurance
Whether you're a motorcycle enthusiast or own an ATV or RV, we can help you find the right insurance coverage for your vehicle. Our motorcycle insurance policy provides liability protection, collision coverage, medical payments, towing and labor, and roadside assistance.
RV and Boat Insurance
We understand the importance of protecting your recreational vehicles, including boats, RVs, and ATVs. Our insurance policies provide coverage for damage, liability, and more.
Contact Us
At McCutcheon Insurance Agency, we are committed to providing exceptional service and expert guidance to our clients. If you have any questions or concerns, please don't hesitate to contact us.
Exceptional Service and Results
The majority of the reviews for McCutcheon Insurance are overwhelmingly positive, with a 5-star rating. Reviewers praise Jennifer and her team for their exceptional service, professionalism, and attention to detail. They note that Jennifer and her team are knowledgeable, helpful, and dedicated to ensuring their clients get the best possible rates and coverage.
Consistent and Reliable
Reviewers highlight the consistency and reliability of McCutcheon Insurance, stating that Jennifer and her team are always available to answer questions, respond to concerns, and resolve issues efficiently. Many reviewers have been with the agency for years, and several have referred friends and family due to their positive experiences.
Personalized Attention and Expertise
Reviewers praise Jennifer's personalized attention and expertise, noting that she takes the time to understand their unique needs and provides tailored solutions. Many reviewers have been able to save money and improve their coverage through Jennifer's expertise.
One Negative Review
In stark contrast, one reviewer, Dan Golias Dan, had a disappointing experience with McCutcheon Insurance, citing poor customer service, lack of communication, and lack of support. He ultimately decided not to renew his policies and did not recommend the agency.
Be the first to review Mccutcheon Insurance Agency.
Write a Review
