Call Now
Website
Call
Business Details
50+ Years
experience
Your Trusted Insurance Partner in Stillwater, MN
Established in 1901, McGarry Kearney Agency is a family-owned insurance agency serving families and businesses in the St. Croix Valley, Stillwater, Minneapolis, Minnesota, and Wisconsin. Our commitment to personalized service distinguishes us from larger corporations, as we prioritize direct client relationships over automated solutions. We specialize in tailoring insurance solutions for home, auto, business, life, and recreational vehicles, leveraging a state-of-the-art computer system to provide instant rate comparisons and efficient policy management. Our team of experienced professionals works exclusively for our clients, advocating on their behalf during claims to ensure fair and prompt settlements.

We represent a curated selection of financially stable insurance carriers, placing policies with providers offering optimal coverage at competitive rates. Our primary objectives include honesty, client-centric service, and fostering long-term trust through transparency and accountability. With over a century of local expertise, we remain dedicated to meeting the evolving insurance needs of our community while maintaining the values that have defined our legacy.
Services
Auto Insurance Business Insurance Home Insurance Life Insurance Recreational Vehicle Insurance
Details
  • Year established: 1901
Highlights and features
  • We have over 120 years of experience serving the St. Croix Valley community.
  • Our independent agency model provides access to multiple insurance carriers.
  • We advocate for clients during claims to ensure fair, prompt settlements.
  • Our state-of-the-art system enables instant rate comparisons and efficient policy management.
  • We prioritize personalized service over automated solutions or call centers.
What people say
Level of service Strong ties with the community Never once had to worry Accommodating, professional, helpful Highly recommended
Services
Auto Insurance
We design customized auto insurance policies to protect vehicles and drivers across Minnesota and Wisconsin. Our policies include collision, liability, and gap coverage options, ensuring financial security for daily commutes and unexpected incidents. Clients benefit from personalized risk assessments and competitive rate comparisons through our independent carrier network.
Business Insurance
Our commercial insurance solutions address unique risks for businesses in the St. Croix Valley, including property, liability, and workers' compensation coverage. We create tailored packages for industries ranging from restaurants to automotive dealerships, combining comprehensive protection with cost-effective strategies for long-term business stability.
Home Insurance
We offer homeowners, condo owners, and renters insurance policies protecting against property damage, personal liability, and living expense disruptions. Our policies cover primary residences and investment properties, with customizable options for high-value homes and specialized assets in Minnesota and Wisconsin communities.
Life Insurance
Our life insurance products provide financial protection for families and dependents, including term and permanent policy options. We help clients determine appropriate coverage amounts based on family needs, retirement plans, and business obligations, ensuring long-term financial stability for beneficiaries.
Recreational Vehicle Insurance
We provide specialized insurance for recreational vehicles including motorhomes, trailers, and boats. Our policies cover damage, theft, and liability risks while offering flexible options for seasonal use and storage. Clients receive tailored protection matching their recreational lifestyle and investment value.
People
Rob McGarry
President
Rob McGarry leads the agency with fourth-generation expertise in insurance services. His leadership emphasizes client advocacy and technological innovation while maintaining the family-owned values established in 1901.
Collin McGarry
Agent
Collin McGarry provides personalized insurance solutions with a focus on emerging risk management needs. He combines technical expertise with community knowledge to serve clients across Minnesota and Wisconsin.
Monica Jones
Agent
Monica Jones specializes in creating customized insurance packages for families and small businesses. Her approach emphasizes clear communication and thorough policy explanations to ensure client understanding and satisfaction.
Questions
What types of insurance do you offer?
We provide auto, home, business, life, and recreational vehicle insurance for clients in Minnesota and Wisconsin.
How are you different from other insurance agencies?
As a family-owned agency since 1901, we offer personalized service with local expertise and independent carrier representation for competitive pricing.
Do you serve businesses outside the St. Croix Valley?
While our office is in Stillwater, we serve businesses throughout Minnesota and Wisconsin with customized commercial insurance solutions.
Can you help with insurance claims?
Yes, we advocate for clients during claims processes to ensure fair and prompt settlements with insurance carriers.
How do you determine insurance rates?
We use a state-of-the-art system for instant rate comparisons across multiple carriers to find competitive pricing for your specific needs.