Protecting your dreams and legacy, one policy at a time.
At Black Insurance Group, we believe that insurance should be more than just a policy - it should be a trusted partnership. That's why our team of licensed, expert agents is dedicated to helping you build a solid foundation for you and your business, providing you with the peace of mind and confidence that comes with knowing you're protected.
As an independent agency, our agents work with premium, trusted insurance carriers without being limited to any single option. This means we can personally provide you the security and confidence that you'll have stability and reliability when you need it most. While no one wants or expects bad things to happen to them, we can't always predict what challenges may come or when they may occur. But having a plan in place when it does is the best line of defense.
Our Services
We offer a wide range of insurance services, including:
- Personal insurance: auto, home, umbrella, life, renters, condo, flood, mobile home, motorcycle, pet, watercraft, and RV insurance
- Business insurance: business owner, property, commercial auto, general liability, workers compensation, commercial umbrella, cyber liability, and management liability
- Policy and claims management: report a claim, certificate of insurance, auto policy cards, and pay online
Our insurance experts will help educate you about your plan, empowering you to make informed decisions and protect your future no matter what comes your way.
Our Story
Black Insurance Group has deep roots in Erie, beginning with our founder, Samuel P. Black II, who founded the Agency on the principle "Insurance with Integrity." We have continued to be committed to that legacy for almost 60 years. In 1962, Black left his thirty-five-year career at Erie Insurance to start his own agency, Samuel P. Black Associates. As an insurance entrepreneur, Black is credited with starting around-the-clock claims service and was known for his early emphasis on customer service.
Our Team
Meet our team of experts, dedicated to providing you with the best insurance experience:
- Kevin Hughes, President
- Cheryl Mantsch, Personal Lines Account Manager
- Baxter, Canine Ambassador
Our Building
Our main office is located in the historic Captain Richards House, built in 1867 in the popular Greek Revival style. Located at 121 East 2nd Street, our building is nestled in the beautiful and historic lakefront district of downtown Erie.
Exceptional Customer Service
The reviews highlight the exceptional customer service provided by the agents, specifically Kevin, Cheryl, and Todd. The agents' extensive knowledge of the industry is praised by the clients, who appreciate their ability to answer questions and provide tailored solutions. The professionalism and responsiveness of the agents are consistently highlighted, with clients feeling valued and treated like family.
Positive Experiences
Clients appreciate the personal touches and tokens of appreciation shown by the agents, making them feel prioritized and valued. The agents' warm and welcoming nature creates a comfortable and stress-free experience for the clients.
Key Strengths
- Extensive industry knowledge
- Professionalism
- Responsiveness
- Friendly and welcoming nature
- Personalized service
- Ability to answer complex questions

Be the first to review Samuel P Black & Associates.
Write a Review