Business Details
Your Trusted Insurance Partner in Westlake, Ohio
Bay Shore Insurance Agency has been serving clients with personalized insurance solutions since our founding. Our team combines decades of industry experience with a commitment to protecting what matters most to our clients. Nancy Kelly, President of Sales, brings 40 years of insurance expertise, while Judie Cunningham, Marketing & Office Manager, contributes 50 years of financial and payroll knowledge. We operate as an independent agency licensed in Ohio, Florida, and Pennsylvania, offering tailored coverage for individuals and businesses.Our affiliations with leading insurers like Travelers, Liberty Mutual, and Grange Insurance ensure comprehensive options for home, auto, and specialty policies. Active in local chambers and community organizations, we prioritize understanding regional needs to deliver relevant protection. With personalized service and a focus on long-term client relationships, we strive to simplify insurance decisions while maintaining transparency and trust.
Services
Home Insurance
Auto Insurance
RV Insurance
Boaters Insurance
Mobile Home Insurance
Motorcycle Insurance
Personal Umbrellas
Rental Insurance
Highlights and features
- 40 years of insurance expertise from our lead agent
- Personalized policy recommendations from multiple carriers
- Deep understanding of local Ohio, Florida, and Pennsylvania markets
- Active community involvement through chamber memberships
- Specialized coverage for unique assets like RVs and boats
Associations and certifications
- Travelers Insurance
- Liberty Mutual Insurance
- Grange Insurance
- SIA of Northern Ohio
- Insurance Board of Northern Ohio
- OIA Ohio Insurance
- Safeco Insurance
Services
Home Insurance
Protect your primary residence and personal belongings with customizable home insurance policies. Our coverage includes structural damage protection, liability coverage, and personal property replacement. We help clients in Ohio, Florida, and Pennsylvania secure policies that match their specific risk profiles and budgetary needs.
Auto Insurance
Comprehensive auto insurance solutions for personal vehicles, including liability, collision, and comprehensive coverage options. We assist clients in selecting appropriate limits and deductibles while offering multi-policy discount opportunities. Our independent agency status allows comparison shopping across multiple carriers.
RV Insurance
Specialized insurance for recreational vehicles including motorhomes, trailers, and campers. Coverage extends to both liability protection and physical damage coverage, with options for custom equipment and roadside assistance. We provide tailored policies for seasonal and year-round RV users.
Boaters Insurance
Protection for watercraft owners through comprehensive boaters insurance policies. Our coverage includes damage from collisions, weather events, and theft, along with liability protection for water-related incidents. We serve clients with various types of boats and personal watercraft.
Personal Umbrellas
Supplemental liability coverage through personal umbrella policies that extend beyond standard home and auto insurance limits. We help clients assess appropriate coverage amounts based on their specific risk exposure and asset protection needs.
People
Nancy Kelly
President of Sales
With 40 years in the insurance industry, Nancy leads sales operations at Bay Shore Insurance Agency. She specializes in connecting clients with appropriate coverage solutions while maintaining active roles in multiple local chambers of commerce.
Judie Cunningham
Marketing & Office Manager
Judie manages agency marketing and office operations, leveraging 50 years of financial industry experience. She focuses on client communication and policy administration while participating in several local business advisory boards.
Questions
What types of insurance does Bay Shore Insurance offer?
We provide home, auto, RV, boaters, mobile home, motorcycle, and rental insurance policies, along with personal umbrella liability coverage.
Do you offer business insurance options?
Yes, we offer commercial insurance including contractors insurance, employment practice liability, and employee benefits plans.
Can I get insurance coverage for multiple states?
We provide policies in Ohio, Florida, and Pennsylvania through our licensed independent agency status.
How can I obtain a free insurance quote?
Contact us directly via phone or through our website's quote request form to receive personalized coverage options.
Are there discounts for multiple insurance policies?
Yes, we offer multi-policy discounts when you bundle home, auto, or other insurance products together.
What payment methods do you accept?
Payment options vary by carrier - please contact our office directly to discuss available payment methods for your specific policy.
Videos
