Call Now
Website
Call
Business Details
Your Trusted Local Insurance Partner Since 1888
Established in 1888, we are a mutual insurance company rooted in the principles of community support and economic resilience. Our agency was founded by local farmers seeking affordable, reliable coverage to protect their livelihoods, and we have remained committed to this mission for over 135 years. As a mutual agency, we prioritize personalized service, tailoring policies to meet the unique needs of homeowners, farmers, and businesses across northwest Iowa. Our team of experienced agents brings over a century of collective expertise, ensuring clients receive comprehensive coverage and clear guidance.

We maintain strong partnerships, including a 65-year relationship with Grinnell Mutual Reinsurance Company, to provide financial security and peace of mind. With offices in Spencer, Iowa, we serve eight counties, offering home, farm, liability, and specialty insurance products. Our dedication to local service, transparency, and client education remains unwavering, reflecting the values that have defined our agency since its inception.
Services
Home Insurance Farm Insurance Liability Insurance Rental Property Insurance Mobile Home Insurance Church & School Insurance Recreational Vehicle Insurance Renters Insurance Inland Marine Insurance Commercial Insurance
Highlights and features
  • We offer over 135 years of experience serving northwest Iowa communities.
  • Our policies are customized to meet your specific coverage needs.
  • We provide local, small-town service with the security of larger companies.
  • Our agents have 100+ years of collective insurance industry expertise.
  • We maintain a 65-year partnership with Grinnell Mutual Reinsurance Company.
Services
Home Insurance
We provide comprehensive home insurance policies protecting against property damage, liability claims, and personal property losses. Our customizable plans ensure homeowners receive coverage tailored to their specific needs and budget. With local expertise and decades of experience, we help clients understand policy details and select appropriate protection levels.
Farm Insurance
Our farm insurance solutions protect agricultural properties, equipment, and livestock against risks like fire, weather damage, and liability claims. Policies include specialized coverage for crop-related assets and farm operations. We work closely with policyholders to create plans that safeguard their livelihoods while complying with industry standards and regulations.
Liability Insurance
We offer liability insurance covering property and personal injury claims for homeowners, businesses, and community organizations. Policies protect against legal costs and settlements arising from accidents on insured properties. Our agents help clients assess risk exposure and select appropriate coverage limits to ensure financial security.
Recreational Vehicle Insurance
Our RV insurance protects campers, snowmobiles, ATVs, and ice fishing shacks against damage, theft, and liability claims. Policies include coverage for both on-road and off-road vehicles, with customizable options for storage and seasonal use. We ensure recreational vehicle owners have reliable protection that matches their specific usage patterns.
Commercial Insurance
We provide commercial insurance solutions for small businesses, including property protection, liability coverage, and workers' compensation. Policies are tailored to specific industries and risk profiles, ensuring businesses have comprehensive protection. Our local agents offer personalized guidance to help companies navigate insurance requirements and mitigate financial risks.
People
Cindy Thompson
Manager/Agent
Cindy Thompson serves as Manager/Agent at Clay Mutual Insurance Association, providing personalized insurance solutions to clients in northwest Iowa. With extensive local knowledge and industry expertise, she helps policyholders navigate coverage options and risk management strategies.
Sara Tyler
Agent
Sara Tyler works as an Agent at Clay Mutual Insurance Association, assisting clients with home, farm, and commercial insurance needs. She focuses on delivering tailored coverage solutions while maintaining the agency's commitment to community-based service and financial security.
Kayla Farghum
Agent
Kayla Farghum serves as an Agent at Clay Mutual Insurance Association, helping clients protect their assets through customized insurance policies. She emphasizes clear communication and client education to ensure policyholders understand their coverage options and risk management strategies.
Questions
What areas do you serve?
We serve eight Iowa counties: Clay, Buena Vista, Cherokee, Dickinson, Emmet, O'Brien, Osceola, Palo Alto, and Pocahontas.
What types of insurance do you offer?
We provide home, farm, liability, rental property, mobile home, church/school, recreational vehicle, and commercial insurance products.
How do I file a claim?
Contact your agent or call us at (712) 262-2240 immediately after a loss. Have your policy ready and document any damages or expenses related to the incident.
What makes you a mutual agency?
As a mutual insurance company, we prioritize policyholder interests over shareholder profits, allowing us to focus on long-term stability and community service.
How are you different from other insurers?
We combine 135+ years of local experience with personalized service, offering tailored policies while maintaining financial strength through our partnership with Grinnell Mutual Reinsurance Company.