Call Now
Website
Call
Business Details
50+ Years
experience
Your Trusted Insurance Partner in Springfield, MO
Established in 1949, we have built a legacy of providing comprehensive insurance and financial solutions to individuals and businesses across Springfield and surrounding areas. Our partnerships with industry leaders like Anthem Blue Cross Blue Shield, Mercy, and Cox allow us to offer tailored coverage options that meet diverse client needs. With decades of experience, we prioritize personalized service, ensuring clients receive innovative solutions for health insurance, employee benefits, and commercial insurance. Our team of licensed professionals is committed to guiding clients through complex insurance landscapes, from Medicare enrollment to marketplace coverage. Recognized as a top insurance broker in Springfield, we maintain affiliations with organizations like Principal Life Insurance Co. and Healthcare.govs Elite Circle of Champions.

Our dedication extends beyond business, as we actively support local communities through annual donations and volunteer efforts. By combining expertise with a client-first approach, we aim to deliver reliable, cost-effective insurance strategies that adapt to evolving needs while upholding our founding mission of creating wealth and security for all clients.
Services
Health Insurance Employee Benefits Commercial Insurance Medicare Products Personal Insurance
Details
  • Year established: 1949
Highlights and features
  • We offer over 70 years of experience in insurance solutions.
  • Our team partners with leading carriers like Anthem Blue Cross Blue Shield.
  • Dedicated to community involvement with annual donations.
  • Real-time customer support without automated systems.
  • Recognized as a top insurance broker in Springfield.
What people say
Informed, experienced, and responsive Huge asset to our company Answer questions promptly Provide accurate information Highly recommend this professional staff
Services
Health Insurance
We provide comprehensive health insurance solutions tailored to individual and family needs. Our expert agents assist with marketplace enrollment, Medicare coverage, and private plans. With partnerships across top insurers, we ensure access to affordable, high-quality healthcare options while guiding clients through policy complexities.
Employee Benefits
Our employee benefits services help businesses design and implement competitive insurance packages. We specialize in group health plans, retirement solutions, and compliance strategies. By partnering with organizations like the Chamber Benefit Plan, we deliver cost-effective benefits that attract talent and support workforce well-being.
Commercial Insurance
We offer tailored commercial insurance policies to protect businesses from operational risks. Coverage includes property, liability, workers' compensation, and commercial auto insurance. Our advisors work closely with clients to create risk management strategies that safeguard assets and ensure business continuity.
Medicare Products
Our Medicare specialists provide guidance on enrollment, supplemental plans, and senior healthcare options. We help clients navigate Medicare Advantage, prescription drug plans, and long-term care solutions. With personalized support, we ensure seniors receive comprehensive coverage that meets their evolving needs.
Personal Insurance
We offer personal insurance products including life, disability, and critical illness coverage. Our agents assess individual needs to recommend policies that provide financial security for families. From term life insurance to accident protection, we deliver solutions that protect personal assets and future plans.
People
Andrea Geyer-Croley
Broker/Co-owner
With over 35 years of experience, Andrea specializes in employee benefits and has served clients since 1986. She holds MS, RHU, and REBC certifications, focusing on tailored benefits solutions for employers and employees.
Tom Croley
Broker, Co-owner
A veteran with over 50 years in insurance, Tom has led Croley Insurance since 1973. Licensed across six Midwestern states, he specializes in connecting clients with comprehensive insurance and financial solutions.
Trevor Croley
President
Trevor focuses on strategic financial planning for individuals and businesses. With expertise in healthcare reform, he helps clients navigate insurance marketplaces and develop long-term financial security strategies.
Deanna Adams
Group Health Specialist
Deanna brings 20+ years of HR experience, specializing in Chamber Benefit Plans and Health Insurance Marketplace enrollment. She provides expert guidance on group health solutions for businesses.
Tiffany Lafferty
Property & Casualty Lead
Tiffany oversees personal and commercial insurance lines with 10+ years of industry experience. Licensed in property and casualty, she manages coverage for auto, home, and business policies.
Questions
What insurance services do you offer?
We provide health insurance, employee benefits, commercial insurance, Medicare products, and personal insurance solutions tailored to individual and business needs.
Are you available outside regular business hours?
Our office hours are 8:00 AM to 5:00 PM Monday through Friday. We do not offer 24/7 services but prioritize prompt daytime support.
Do you serve areas beyond Springfield?
Yes, we serve Springfield and surrounding areas in Missouri, with licenses to operate in six Midwestern states for specific insurance products.
What payment methods do you accept?
We accept standard payment methods for insurance premiums. Contact our office for specific details about payment options for your policy.
How do you support local communities?
We contribute nearly $15,000 annually to local organizations and encourage staff volunteerism, reflecting our commitment to the Springfield community since 1949.
What sets you apart from other insurers?
Our 70+ years of local experience, partnerships with major carriers, and personalized service distinguish us as a trusted insurance advisor in the region.