Business Details
44 Years
experience
Emergency
services
Your Trusted Independent Insurance Agency in Webster, NY
Founded in 1982, Steinmiller Insurance has served thousands of customers across Upstate New York for over three decades. As an independent agency, we prioritize personalized service, offering tailored insurance solutions for personal and commercial needs. Our team works directly with clients to compare policies from multiple carriers, ensuring competitive pricing and comprehensive coverage. With a focus on local community involvement, we provide accessible, responsive support, including direct communication channels with agents.Our commitment to excellence spans residential, automotive, business, and specialty insurance products, backed by continuous policy reviews to adapt to evolving client needs. Headquartered in Webster, NY, we combine decades of industry experience with a family-oriented approach to client relationships.
Services
Business Insurance
Residential Insurance
Vehicle Insurance
Flood Insurance
Life Insurance
Long Term Care
Umbrella Coverage
Wedding Insurance
Details
- Year established: 1982
Highlights and features
- We've provided personalized insurance solutions since 1982.
- Our independent agency offers policies from multiple carriers.
- Local agents provide direct, responsive communication.
- We continuously review policies to ensure optimal coverage.
- Our team specializes in both personal and commercial insurance.
What people say
Knowledgeable staff
Responsive communication
Excellent service
Competitive rates
Personalized attention
Services
Business Insurance
We offer comprehensive business insurance solutions including general liability, auto coverage, and workers' compensation. Our policies protect against property damage, legal liabilities, and employee-related risks. Specializing in customized packages for small to mid-sized enterprises across multiple industries.
Residential Insurance
Our residential insurance provides coverage for homes, condos, and rental properties with options for high-value homes exceeding $300,000. Policies include protection against fire, theft, and natural disasters while offering liability coverage for homeowner-related incidents.
Vehicle Insurance
We provide vehicle insurance for cars, boats, motorcycles, and RVs with coverage for liability, collision, and comprehensive damages. Our policies meet New York state requirements while offering additional protections for specialized vehicles and equipment.
Flood Insurance
Flood insurance policies cover direct physical losses from flooding events. This specialized coverage protects properties against water damage from rising water levels, storm surges, and other flood-related incidents not typically included in standard home insurance.
Life Insurance
Our life insurance products provide financial security for beneficiaries in the event of policyholder death. Policies help replace lost income, cover final expenses, and support long-term financial planning for families and dependents.
People
Gary Steinmiller
Founder & Chairman
With over 45 years in insurance, Gary established Steinmiller Insurance in 1982. He built a legacy of personalized service, now continued by his daughters while maintaining active oversight.
Kristen Steinmiller
President
President with two decades of experience specializing in commercial and personal insurance policies. Focuses on client relationships and maintaining the agency's family-oriented service culture.
Robyn Steinmiller
Vice President
Licensed since 2004, Robyn specializes in property, casualty, and health insurance. Prioritizes making insurance accessible while maintaining multi-channel client communication.
Laurie Sweet
Account Executive
With 30+ years in insurance, Laurie focuses on delivering excellent service through honest advice and leveraging long-standing client relationships.
Mike Shay
Commercial Lines Consultant
Specializes in advanced commercial insurance solutions including cyber liability and contractors' programs. Provides risk management expertise for diverse industries.
Questions
What types of insurance does Steinmiller offer?
We provide home, auto, business, flood, life, and specialty insurance including RV, boat, and wedding coverage.
How can I get insurance quotes?
Contact us directly via phone or visit our Webster office to receive personalized quotes from multiple insurance carriers.
Do you offer 24/7 claims support?
Yes, we provide 24/7 accident assistance and claims reporting through our toll-free emergency line.
Are you a local agency?
Yes, we're based in Webster, NY and have served Upstate New York communities since 1982.
Can you help with policy reviews?
We continuously monitor policies to ensure optimal coverage and cost-effectiveness for our clients.
Do you work with multiple insurance carriers?
As an independent agency, we represent multiple carriers to find the best coverage options for clients.
