Take Pride in protecting what matters most.
At Carlisle Insurance, we take pride in providing quality insurance solutions since 1925. Our family of trusted experts proudly provides you with personalized coverage plans to protect your business and family now and in the future. We build our protection around the ideals of strength, security, and stability, so you can keep moving forward through whatever life throws your way. When you put your trust in Carlisle Insurance, you can take pride knowing we work hard to provide the coverage that matters most.
Our Philosophy
Our philosophy is rooted in understanding what it means to be proud of what you have, and how important it is to know that it is protected. We are proud to offer the strength to protect you when you need it most, the security of a plan tailored to your needs, and the stability of an enduring insurance agency. We believe that by putting our customers first and taking the time to understand their specific needs, we can provide the right coverage to give them peace of mind in the future.
Our Services
At Carlisle Insurance, we offer a comprehensive range of services to cater to the diverse needs of our clients. Our services include:
- Commercial Insurance: We take pride in creating customized commercial insurance coverage plans that meet the specific needs of your business. We work hard to accurately assess your exposures and provide the best value by finding the perfect coverage with the highest-rated insurance carriers.
- Employee Benefits: We understand the importance of protecting your company's biggest asset - its employees. We take pride in finding the right employee benefits plan that fits your specific business and employee needs.
- Personal Insurance: Our personal insurance options give you the peace of mind when the unexpected happens. From home and personal auto insurance to life insurance, we help protect your life now and for the future.
Our Expertise
We have extensive expertise in a wide range of industries, including:
- Oil & Gas: We understand the unique challenges and risks faced by the oil and gas industry. We work hard to provide expert advice and tailored coverage solutions to meet your specific needs.
- Windstorm: We have extensive experience in providing windstorm coverage to individuals and businesses in high-risk areas.
- Trucking: We understand the importance of providing comprehensive coverage for trucking companies, including public liability and physical damage coverage.
- Hotel & Motel: We provide customized coverage solutions for hotel and motel owners, including property and liability coverage.
Why Choose Carlisle Insurance
At Carlisle Insurance, we take pride in being a trusted partner for our clients. We work hard to find the right coverage plan that fits your specific needs, and we are committed to providing exceptional customer service and claims support. We have a long history of satisfied clients who have entrusted us with their insurance needs, and we would be honored to do the same for you.
Read What Our Clients Say
We've had the pleasure of serving many satisfied clients over the years. Here's what some of them have to say about our services:
- "I have used Carlisle Ins for the resources provided - the personalized service you provide, Zywave, and ThinkHR. I have used these services more than I can tell you. Without these resources, I would be at a loss!" - Vilma A. Cosneros, Coil Solutions, Inc.
- "Carlisle Insurance Agency has provided FESCO Ltd. with exceptional service in all facets of our insurance needs." - Steve Findley, President, FESCO Ltd.
Overall Experience
The reviews highlight the contrasting experiences of customers with Carlisle Insurance Company. Some customers have had positive interactions, praising the company's fast service, multiple options, and honest quotes. On the other hand, some customers have had negative experiences, citing issues with slow customer service, untrustworthy quotes, and unresponsive representatives.
Pricing and Quotes
There are concerns about the accuracy of quoted rates, with one customer expressing frustration over being told their rate was higher than initially quoted. Another customer appreciated the honest and fair quotes provided by the company.
Customer Service
The reviews highlight the variability in customer service experiences. While some customers have had positive interactions, others have experienced slow response times, unreturned calls, and poor communication.

Be the first to review Carlisle Insurance.
Write a Review