The coverage you need. The service you deserve.
A Legacy of Serving South Jersey since 1922
McMahon Insurance Agency boasts a rich history of providing comprehensive and personalized insurance solutions to families, businesses, and professionals throughout South Jersey. Founded in 1922 and now spanning three convenient locations in Ocean City, Marmora, and Cape May, our agency has weathered countless storms alongside our clients, offering consistent guidance and support.
Driven by Your Needs
Our team of knowledgeable and experienced professionals takes the time to understand your unique risks and goals. We offer a diverse range of insurance plans to address every aspect of your life, including:
Personal Insurance
- Auto & Vehicle Insurance
- Homeowners & Renters Insurance
- Flood & Water Damage Insurance
- Life & Health Insurance
- Umbrella & Excess Liability Insurance
Business Insurance
- Business Property & Liability Insurance
- Commercial Auto Insurance
- Workers' Compensation Insurance
- Cyber Liability Insurance
- Group Health & Benefits Insurance
Expert Guidance and Personalized Support
At McMahon Insurance Agency, we believe in open communication and personalized service. Our dedicated account managers will guide you through the process of choosing the right coverage and handling any claims with efficiency and compassion.
What Sets Us Apart?
- Experience and Expertise: Decades of experience in various fields ensure comprehensive understanding of diverse risks.
- Personalized Service: Focused on building lasting relationships with clients through individualized attention and responsive communication.
- Local Expertise: Deeply rooted in the community, with intimate knowledge of the unique challenges and opportunities of the area.
- Competitive Pricing: Access to competitive rates and comprehensive coverage options.
Empowering Your Insurance Journey
McMahon Insurance Agency empowers you to make informed decisions regarding your insurance needs. We provide comprehensive information, transparent explanations, and ongoing support throughout the process. Our agency thrives on building strong relationships and becoming trusted partners in your financial security.
Overview of McMahon Insurance Agency
McMahon Insurance Agency has received an overwhelmingly positive response from its customers, with many reviewers praising the agency's exceptional service, professionalism, and expertise.
Excellent Customer Service
Many reviewers highlighted the agency's excellent customer service, citing prompt responses, clear explanations, and a high level of professionalism. Angela Wolfe, Kathleen Ward, Joan, Bonnie Ash, and other agents were specifically mentioned for their outstanding service.
Professionalism and Expertise
Reviewers praised the agency's professionalism and expertise, stating that they were knowledgeable and helpful in finding the right insurance coverage for their needs. The agency's ability to explain complex insurance terms in a clear and concise manner was also commended.
Efficient and Responsive
The agency's efficiency and responsiveness were also highlighted, with many reviewers mentioning that their queries were addressed promptly and that the agency was able to provide quick solutions to their insurance needs.
Highly Recommended
Many reviewers highly recommended McMahon Insurance Agency, stating that they would use the agency again and recommend it to others.

Be the first to review McMahon Insurance Agency.
Write a Review