Call Now
Website
Call
Business Details
50+ Years
experience
Your Trusted Missouri Insurance Partner
MHJ Insurance has been dedicated to protecting families, friends, and neighbors since 1935. As an independent full-service agency, we offer personalized insurance solutions for auto, home, life, health, and commercial needs. Our commitment to exceptional customer service and integrity has been the cornerstone of our success, with a team of over 50 professional agents serving communities across Missouri, Illinois, and Arkansas.

We combine decades of experience with a deep understanding of local markets to provide competitive rates and tailored coverage options. Our clients value our transparent approach, expert claim handling, and the peace of mind that comes from working with a trusted, locally rooted agency.
Services
Auto Insurance Homeowners Insurance Business Insurance Life & Health Insurance Employee Benefits
Details
  • Year established: 1935
Highlights and features
  • We offer over 85 years of combined insurance expertise since 1935
  • Our local offices provide personalized service tailored to community needs
  • We shop multiple carriers to find the best rates and coverage options
  • Our team of 50+ professional agents delivers specialized insurance solutions
  • We maintain transparent operations with a proven track record of customer satisfaction
What people say
Friendly and trustworthy agents Personal approach Exceptional customer service Competitive rates Expert claim handling
Services
Auto Insurance
We provide comprehensive auto insurance solutions tailored to individual needs, including liability coverage, collision protection, and uninsured motorist options. Our team shops multiple carriers to find competitive rates while ensuring adequate protection for vehicles and drivers. With expertise in state-specific requirements, we help clients navigate coverage options for cars, trucks, motorcycles, and specialty vehicles.
Business Insurance
Our business insurance packages protect commercial enterprises with customized coverage for property damage, liability, workers' compensation, and cyber risks. We specialize in creating cost-effective solutions for small to mid-sized businesses, including builders risk, equipment breakdown, and professional liability coverage. Our agents understand industry-specific risks and help maintain operational continuity through tailored insurance strategies.
Homeowners Insurance
We offer homeowners insurance policies that protect against property damage, liability claims, and personal property loss. Our coverage options include basic, broad, and special form policies with additional protection for earthquakes, floods, and equipment breakdowns. We help clients secure replacement cost coverage for personal belongings and provide expert guidance through the claims process.
Life & Health Insurance
Our life and health insurance solutions provide financial security for families during hardship or loss. We partner with trusted providers to offer term life, whole life, and health insurance policies tailored to individual needs. Our agents help clients understand policy options and select coverage that protects loved ones while maintaining affordability.
Employee Benefits
We assist employers with comprehensive employee benefits packages including health insurance, retirement plans, and HR management systems. Our services cover ACA compliance, benefits administration, and workplace risk mitigation. We provide web-based tools for enrollment, time-off tracking, and regulatory filings to simplify benefits management for businesses of all sizes.
People
Lara L. Moffitt
Principal / President / CEO / Agency Co-manager
Lara L. Moffitt leads MHJ Insurance with over two decades of insurance industry experience. She oversees strategic operations while maintaining a client-focused approach to insurance solutions.
Charles Moffitt
Principal / Chairman of Board / CFO
Charles Moffitt brings extensive financial expertise to Heartland Group, managing agency finances and long-term strategic planning while maintaining a hands-on approach to client relationships.
Kyle McHugh
Producer
Kyle McHugh specializes in personal insurance solutions, earning client recognition for his friendly service and ability to explain complex insurance concepts in accessible terms.
Jeff Boner
Principal / Secretary / PR Officer
Jeff Boner manages public relations and agency operations, combining insurance expertise with community engagement to strengthen Heartland Group's local presence.
Ruth Ann Moffitt
CSR
Ruth Ann Moffitt provides exceptional client support as a customer service representative, known for her attention to detail and commitment to resolving client insurance needs efficiently.
Questions
What types of insurance do you offer?
We provide auto, home, life, health, business insurance, and employee benefits packages tailored to individual and commercial needs.
Do you serve areas outside Missouri?
Yes, we serve clients in Illinois, Arkansas, and surrounding regions through our network of local offices.
How can I get a free insurance quote?
Contact us via phone or our website to speak with an agent who will help you compare coverage options at no cost.
Are your insurance agents licensed locally?
Yes, all our agents are Missouri-licensed with expertise in state-specific insurance requirements and local market conditions.
Can you help with insurance claims?
Our team provides expert claim assistance, guiding clients through the process to ensure timely and fair resolutions.
Do you offer online account management?
Yes, we provide web-based tools for policy management, claims filing, and employee benefits administration through secure portals.