Ellington Mutual Insurance

Ellington Mutual Insurance is proud to be a trusted name in Wisconsin for over 145 years. We've built our reputation on providing comprehensive insurance coverage and unwavering customer service to individuals, families, and businesses across the state. Our commitment to our clients is simple: to understand their unique needs and provide tailored solutions that offer peace of mind and financial security.

A Legacy of Excellence

Rooted in the heart of Wisconsin, Ellington Mutual Insurance has served generations of policyholders with unwavering dedication. Our long-standing history is a testament to our commitment to building lasting relationships based on trust, transparency, and exceptional service. We take pride in being a locally-owned and operated company, deeply invested in the well-being of the communities we serve.

Your Partner in Protection

At Ellington Mutual Insurance, we believe that everyone deserves access to reliable insurance coverage that fits their individual circumstances. We offer a wide range of insurance products designed to protect what matters most to you, from your home and personal belongings to your business and farm operations.

Our comprehensive homeowner's insurance policies provide comprehensive coverage for your dwelling, personal property, and liability. We understand that renting can also present unique needs, which is why we offer tailored renter's insurance policies designed to safeguard your belongings against theft, damage, and other covered perils.

Landlords can rely on our specialized landlord insurance policies to protect their investment properties, ensuring coverage for both the structure and the contents. Our diverse portfolio of insurance options extends to encompass farm and agricultural properties, including specialized policies for farm operations, equipment, and hobby farms.

Personalized Service, Exceptional Results

We believe in making insurance understandable and accessible. Our team of expert agents is dedicated to providing personalized guidance and support to help you navigate the complexities of insurance and choose the right coverage for your needs. We take the time to listen to your concerns, answer all your questions, and ensure you feel confident and protected.

Committing to Enhanced Service

As of January 1, 2024, Ellington Mutual Insurance will be merging with Homestead Mutual Insurance. This strategic alliance signals a commitment to even stronger service for our valued policyholders. While the name may change, our dedication to personalized care, exceptional coverage, and local expertise will remain at the forefront of everything we do. We anticipate this integration will empower us to deliver an even more enhanced experience, leveraging the combined resources of both companies to better serve our clients.