Call Now
Website
Call
Business Details
50+ Years
experience
Your Trusted Insurance Partner in Monroe, MI
Schafer Agency has served Monroe County for over a century, providing four generations of dedicated insurance expertise. Our agency specializes in both personal and commercial insurance solutions, offering comprehensive coverage from carefully selected A-rated carriers. We prioritize risk management, identifying coverage gaps to deliver tailored protection that safeguards clients' assets and future.

With three convenient locations across Michigan, our team of licensed professionals works tirelessly to simplify the insurance process, ensuring clients receive personalized service and competitive rates. Our mission focuses on alleviating client concerns by providing reliable coverage and responsive support during claims, maintaining a legacy of trust and community commitment since 1926.
Services
Auto Insurance Homeowners Insurance Business Insurance Life Insurance RV Insurance Commercial Auto Workers Compensation General Liability Farm Insurance
Details
  • Year established: 1926
Highlights and features
  • We offer 100 years of combined insurance expertise serving Monroe County
  • Our team represents carefully selected A-rated insurance carriers
  • We provide personalized policy customization for unique client needs
  • We maintain three convenient Michigan locations with local expertise
  • Our agents deliver dedicated claims support and risk management guidance
What people say
Top notch service for 20+ years Brenda is a gem to work with Made everything easy to understand Honest guy with fair pricing Highly recommend for 30 years
Services
Auto Insurance
Our auto insurance policies protect Michigan drivers against financial losses from accidents, theft, or vehicle damage. We offer comprehensive coverage options including liability protection, collision coverage, and uninsured motorist protection. Our agents help clients navigate Michigan's unique insurance requirements while finding competitive rates tailored to individual driving profiles and vehicle types.
Business Insurance
We provide customized commercial insurance packages protecting Michigan businesses from industry-specific risks. Coverage options include general liability, workers compensation, commercial property, and business interruption insurance. Our agents help businesses identify risk exposures and create comprehensive protection plans that meet regulatory requirements while safeguarding assets and operations.
Homeowners Insurance
Our homeowners insurance policies protect Monroe County residences against common risks including fire, theft, and weather damage. Coverage includes dwelling protection, personal property coverage, and liability protection for property owners. We offer specialized endorsements for unique needs and help clients understand coverage requirements for mortgage compliance.
Life Insurance
We offer term and permanent life insurance solutions providing financial security for families and dependents. Our policies include death benefit protection with options for cash value accumulation. Our agents help clients evaluate coverage needs based on income replacement requirements, outstanding debts, and long-term financial planning objectives.
Recreational Vehicle Insurance
Our RV insurance policies protect various recreational vehicles including motorhomes, travel trailers, and off-road vehicles. Coverage includes liability protection, collision coverage, and specialized equipment protection. We help clients understand state requirements for RV insurance and create customized policies that protect their recreational investments.
People
Greg Schafer
Licensed Agent
With extensive insurance expertise, Greg Schafer provides personalized policy solutions, focusing on fair pricing and client education. He builds long-term relationships through transparent communication and dedicated service.
Brenda Schuster
Elite Licensed Agent
Brenda Schuster combines deep insurance knowledge with exceptional client service, helping clients navigate complex coverage options and providing expert guidance during policy transitions.
Larry Schafer
Licensed Agent
Larry Schafer brings decades of experience in commercial insurance, specializing in risk assessment and comprehensive business protection strategies for Michigan companies.
Donna Dyda
Licensed Agent
Donna Dyda assists clients with personal insurance needs, leveraging her expertise to create customized protection plans that balance coverage and affordability.
Tony Marvaso
Licensed Agent
Tony Marvaso provides specialized insurance solutions, focusing on client education and helping individuals and businesses understand their coverage options.
Questions
What types of insurance does Schafer Agency offer?
We provide auto, home, life, business, farm, recreational vehicle, and specialty insurance products tailored to Michigan residents and businesses.
How can I get a personalized insurance quote?
Contact our Monroe office at 734-242-5100 or request a quote online to speak with an agent who will assess your specific needs.
Do you offer commercial insurance for small businesses?
Yes, we create customized business insurance packages including liability, property, and workers compensation coverage for Michigan businesses.
Are your insurance agents licensed in Michigan?
All our agents maintain active Michigan insurance licenses and professional designations like CIC and CISR.
How does your claims assistance work?
We guide clients through the entire claims process, advocating on their behalf and ensuring timely resolution of all covered claims.
Can you help with insurance for unique properties?
Yes, we offer specialized coverage options for farms, recreational properties, and unique homes requiring additional protection.