Business Details
50+ Years
experience
Emergency
services
Your Trusted Independent Insurance Agency in Fort Wayne, IN
Fort Wayne Car Insurance has been a trusted independent insurance partner since 1975, dedicated to protecting individuals and businesses in Fort Wayne, IN. As a family-owned agency spanning three generations, we combine over 120 years of collective industry experience with a personalized approach to insurance solutions. Our team works with a diverse network of reputable carriers to offer tailored coverage options for home, auto, umbrella, motorcycle, renters, and commercial insurance.We prioritize client relationships over corporate interests, ensuring transparent advice and advocacy during claims. Our mission focuses on delivering comprehensive protection that balances affordability with robust coverage, treating every client like family. With affiliations like the National Alliance for Insurance and recognition as Indiana Farmers' Agency of the Year, we maintain rigorous professional standards while adapting to evolving client needs.
Services
Home Insurance
Auto Insurance
Umbrella Insurance
Commercial Insurance
Renters Insurance
Motorcycle Insurance
General Liability
Business Property
Loss of Income
Excess Liability
Details
- Year established: 1975
Highlights and features
- We have over 45 years of experience insuring Northern Indiana communities.
- Our family-owned agency offers three generations of insurance expertise.
- We work with 20+ reputable carriers to find your optimal coverage mix.
- Our team provides 24/7 support for claims and policy emergencies.
- We maintain industry-leading certifications including CIC and PLCS designations.
Services
Home Insurance
Our home insurance protects your primary asset with coverage for fire, theft, liability, and natural disasters. We offer replacement cost coverage, personal property protection, and umbrella policy integration. Policies include additional living expense coverage during repairs and scheduled property endorsements for high-value items. With flood and earthquake coverage options, we address regional risks specific to Northern Indiana properties.
Commercial Insurance
We provide comprehensive business insurance including general liability, property protection, and income loss coverage. Our policies protect against equipment damage, client injuries, and operational interruptions. Specialized options cover childcare centers, food trucks, and professional liability. We offer commercial umbrella policies to extend standard coverage limits for businesses in manufacturing, retail, and service sectors across Allen County.
Auto Insurance
Our auto insurance includes liability, collision, and comprehensive coverage meeting Indiana legal requirements. We offer uninsured motorist protection, rental reimbursement, and custom parts coverage. Policies protect against weather damage, theft, and medical expenses from accidents. We specialize in high-risk driver solutions and multi-policy discounts while maintaining 24/7 claims support for accident emergencies.
Umbrella Insurance
Umbrella policies extend liability coverage beyond standard home and auto policies. We provide $1M+ coverage tiers that activate when primary policy limits are exhausted. This protects assets against catastrophic claims from property damage, bodily injury, or lawsuits. Coverage applies across multiple policies and includes legal defense costs exceeding base policy limits.
Renters Insurance
Our renters insurance protects personal property against fire, theft, and water damage. Policies include liability coverage for guest injuries and premises liability. We offer additional living expense reimbursement and scheduled coverage for valuables like electronics and jewelry. Policies meet landlord requirements while protecting tenants' belongings against common risks in apartment communities.
People
Susan Schultheis Beauchot
Agency Owner & Account Executive
Third-generation insurance leader with MBA and CIC certification. Oversees agency operations while maintaining client relationships. Recognized for combining family legacy with modern insurance solutions.
Adam Beauchot
Account Executive
PLCS and CLCS certified agent specializing in commercial risk management. Focuses on business owner policies and liability solutions for manufacturing and service industries in Northeast Indiana.
Mark Beauchot
Agency Manager
Coordinates team operations and client service protocols. Ensures efficient policy administration and claims processing. Maintains agency compliance with insurance regulations and carrier requirements.
Questions
What types of insurance does Schultheis Agency offer?
We provide home, auto, motorcycle, renters, umbrella, and commercial insurance. Specialized options include food truck coverage, childcare center policies, and collector vehicle insurance.
How does being an independent agency benefit clients?
We access 20+ insurance carriers to compare pricing and coverage options. This independence allows unbiased recommendations tailored to your specific protection needs and budget.
What areas do you serve?
Our primary service area includes Fort Wayne, New Haven, Auburn, and surrounding communities in Northern Indiana. We also assist clients statewide with remote consultations.
How quickly can I get insurance coverage?
Most policies can be quoted and issued within 24 hours. Our team prioritizes urgent coverage needs and offers same-day consultations for emergency insurance requirements.
Do you handle insurance claims assistance?
We provide 24/7 claims support to guide you through the process. Our team advocates on your behalf with insurance companies to ensure fair and timely claim resolutions.
What sets your agency apart from online insurers?
We combine local market knowledge with personalized service. Our agents explain complex insurance terms in plain language and maintain ongoing policy reviews to ensure continued coverage adequacy.