Business Details
50+ Years
experience
Your Trusted Insurance Partner in Lima, Ohio
Founded in 1906, Webb Insurance Agency has grown from a single policy sale to become the largest independent insurance agency in West Central Ohio. With two locations in Lima and Bluffton, our agency operates five specialized departmentsPersonal Insurance, Business Insurance, Fixed Life Insurance, Health & Group Benefits, and Claimseach staffed by experienced professionals committed to personalized service. Our team of 30+ experts combines deep industry knowledge with a client-centric approach, ensuring tailored insurance solutions for both individuals and businesses.Over a century of experience informs our risk evaluation strategies, whether protecting personal assets or developing comprehensive commercial coverage. We prioritize transparency, offering straightforward guidance to help clients navigate complex insurance needs. Our dedication to excellence is reflected in our long-standing relationships with thousands of satisfied policyholders across the region.
Services
Personal Insurance
Business Insurance
Fixed Life Insurance
Health & Group Benefits
Claims Advocacy
Home Insurance
Auto Insurance
Commercial Coverage
Disability Insurance
Annuities
Details
- Year established: 1906
Highlights and features
- We offer over a century of insurance expertise serving West Central Ohio
- Our 30+ experienced professionals specialize in tailored risk management
- Five dedicated departments handle all personal and commercial insurance needs
- We provide personalized service with no hidden fees or complex jargon
- Dedicated claims team advocates for fair and timely policyholder resolutions
Services
Personal Insurance
We provide comprehensive coverage for personal assets including homes, vehicles, and valuable possessions. Our policies protect against property damage, liability claims, and unexpected losses while offering customizable options for modern lifestyles. Our experienced agents help clients select appropriate coverage limits and risk management strategies.
Business Insurance
Our commercial insurance solutions protect businesses from operational risks through property, liability, and specialized coverage options. We assess each company's unique exposures to create tailored packages that include general liability, professional liability, and equipment protection for businesses of all sizes.
Claims Advocacy
Our dedicated claims team guides policyholders through the entire claims process from initial reporting to settlement. We provide expert documentation assistance, coordinate with adjusters, and ensure fair compensation while minimizing client stress during difficult situations.
Health & Group Benefits
We design comprehensive health insurance and benefits packages for individuals and businesses. Our offerings include medical, dental, vision, disability, and retirement plans with personalized guidance to help clients navigate complex coverage options and regulatory requirements.
Life Insurance
Our life insurance solutions provide financial security for families and business partners through term, whole life, and universal life policies. We offer payroll deduction options for employers and help clients structure policies to meet estate planning and income replacement needs.
People
Thomas Sarno-CPCU
CEO
Thomas Sarno-CPCU leads Webb Insurance Agency with over 30 years of industry experience. He specializes in commercial risk management and holds the Chartered Property Casualty Underwriter designation, ensuring strategic leadership for the agency's growth and client service standards.
Michael Sarno-CPCU
Agent
Michael Sarno-CPCU provides expert insurance solutions with specialized knowledge in commercial lines. As an Associate in General Insurance, he helps businesses develop comprehensive risk management strategies while maintaining the agency's commitment to personalized service.
Richard Moening-CPCU
President
Richard Moening-CPCU serves as President with extensive expertise in insurance operations. His Chartered Property Casualty Underwriter credentials support strategic decision-making and client relationship management, maintaining the agency's reputation for industry leadership and community service.
Nick Sarno
Claims Manager
Nick Sarno leads the claims department with a focus on efficient resolution and client advocacy. He ensures policyholders receive timely support through complex claims processes while maintaining the agency's commitment to transparent communication and fair outcomes.
Mark Altstaetter
Life Insurance Agent
Mark Altstaetter specializes in life insurance and financial planning solutions. As a registered investment advisor, he helps clients protect their families' futures through customized term and permanent life insurance policies while providing retirement planning expertise.
Questions
What types of insurance does Webb Insurance Agency offer?
We provide personal insurance (home, auto, life), business insurance (property, liability), health & group benefits, and specialized coverage for farms, recreational vehicles, and commercial equipment.
How can I file an insurance claim?
Contact our claims department directly at (419)228-3211 (Lima) or (419)358-4015 (Bluffton). Our team will guide you through documentation requirements and coordinate with insurers for timely resolution.
Do you serve businesses of all sizes?
Yes, our commercial insurance services cater to sole proprietors, small businesses, and multi-million dollar corporations with customized risk management solutions.
Are your agents licensed professionals?
All our insurance professionals maintain industry certifications including CPCU (Chartered Property Casualty Underwriter) and AINS (Associate in General Insurance) designations.
What are your office hours?
Our Lima and Bluffton offices operate Monday-Friday 8:00 AM - 5:00 PM. Claims assistance is available during regular business hours for urgent matters.