James T Lahey Agency

At James T. Lahey Agency, we pride ourselves on being a trusted and reliable insurance agency in Potsdam, NY. With a rich history dating back to 1947, our agency has been locally owned and operated, serving the North Country and surrounding communities. We're committed to providing exceptional service and customized insurance solutions to meet your unique needs.

As an independent insurance agency, we represent multiple carriers, offering a wide range of insurance products, including home, auto, renters, and small business insurance. Our experienced team of licensed agents and customer service representatives will work with you to evaluate your insurance needs and help you choose the best insurance plan and carrier. With multiple carriers at our disposal, we can offer competitive rates and a tailored insurance plan that meets your specific requirements.

Our History

The James T. Lahey Insurance Agency, Inc. has been serving the North Country for over seven decades. Our agency was founded by James T. Lahey in 1947, and since then, we've been committed to providing excellent service and insurance solutions to our clients.

Meet The Team

Our team consists of two licensed insurance agents, Steve Yianoukos and Mark Goodnow, and two customer service representatives, Lisa Curry and Michelle Hayes. Together, we have a deep understanding of the insurance industry and are dedicated to providing exceptional service and expertise to our clients.

Carriers

We represent the following insurance carriers:

• Allstate Insurance
• Main Street America Insurance
• NY Central Mutual Insurance
• Progressive Insurance
• Erie & Niagara Insurance
• Merchants Insurance
• Old Dominion Insurance
• Travelers Insurance
• Haggerty Classic Auto Insurance
• National Grange Insurance
• Otsego Mutual Insurance

Claims and Bill Pay Information

We understand that unexpected events can occur, and that's why we're committed to helping you navigate the claims process. Our team is here to assist you in filing a claim or resolving any insurance-related issues. Below, you'll find the contact information for our insurance carriers:

• Allstate: (800) 366-3495
• Main Street America: (877) 425-2467
• NY Central Mutual: (800) 234-6926
• Progressive: (800) 776-4737
• Erie & Niagara: (800) 234-9876
• Merchants: (800) 462-8182
• Old Dominion: (866) 335-0509
• Travelers: (800) 252-4633
• Haggerty Classic Auto: (800) 385-0274
• National Grange: (877) 425-2467
• Otsego Mutual: (607) 965-8211

Bill Pay Information:

You can pay your insurance premiums directly with your carrier. Below, you'll find the contact information for our insurance carriers:

• Allstate: (800) 901-1732
• Main Street America: (866) 335-0509
• NY Central Mutual: (800) 234-6926
• Progressive: (800) 776-4737
• Erie & Niagara: (800) 234-9876
• Merchants: (800) 462-8182
• Old Dominion: (866) 335-0509
• Travelers: (800) 842-5075
• Haggerty Classic Auto: (800) 385-0274
• National Grange: (866) 335-0509
• Otsego Mutual: (607) 965-8211

Contact Us

Please feel free to contact us with any questions or concerns you may have. We're committed to providing exceptional service and helping our clients navigate the insurance process.