Call Now
Website
Call
Business Details
Custom Insurance Solutions for Individuals & Businesses
At Mayville Tremaine, we understand life's complexities demand reliable protection. Our team of seasoned insurance professionals has dedicated decades to helping individuals and businesses secure tailored coverage that aligns with their unique needs. We specialize in navigating the insurance landscape to find optimal policies across personal and commercial lines, ensuring our clients receive comprehensive protection at competitive prices.

Our approach combines personalized service with extensive industry expertise, prioritizing client education and transparency throughout the process. With a focus on long-term relationships, we strive to be a trusted partner in safeguarding our clients' assets and future endeavors.
Services
Homeowners Insurance Auto Insurance Commercial Lines Cyber Liability Special Event Insurance Condominium Coverage Motorcycle Insurance Workers Compensation Umbrella Policies Flood Insurance
Highlights and features
  • Decades of experience in personal and commercial insurance markets
  • Personalized policy comparisons across multiple insurance carriers
  • Specialized expertise in high net worth and complex risk coverage
  • Dedicated claims support throughout the resolution process
  • Local knowledge with national industry connections
Services
Commercial Insurance
Our commercial insurance solutions protect businesses of all sizes against industry-specific risks. We offer tailored policies for manufacturers, municipalities, nonprofits, and special events. Our brokers work directly with clients to assess exposures and secure comprehensive coverage packages that include property protection, liability safeguards, and specialized endorsements.
Personal Insurance
We provide customized personal insurance programs for homeowners, vehicle owners, and high-net-worth individuals. Our offerings include standard and specialty coverage options for condominiums, watercraft, collector cars, and umbrella policies. Our team ensures clients receive balanced protection that matches their lifestyle and asset profile.
Claims Assistance
Our dedicated claims specialists guide policyholders through the entire claims process. We provide step-by-step support from initial reporting to final resolution, helping clients navigate documentation requirements and communicate effectively with insurance carriers to ensure fair and timely claim settlements.
Cyber Liability
We offer cyber liability insurance solutions to protect businesses against digital threats. Our policies cover data breaches, network security failures, and cyber extortion incidents. We work with clients to implement risk management strategies while securing financial protection for potential cyber incidents.
Special Event Insurance
Our event insurance programs provide temporary protection for special occasions. We offer liability coverage, liquor liability, and property protection for weddings, festivals, and corporate events. Policies are customized to meet venue requirements and specific risk exposures.
People
Kurt Eimiller
President
With over 25 years in insurance leadership, Kurt Eimiller oversees strategic operations and client relationships. He specializes in commercial risk management and maintains key carrier partnerships to benefit client coverage options.
Chris Hernandez
Commercial Lines
Chris brings 15 years of commercial insurance expertise, focusing on manufacturing risks and municipal coverage. He helps businesses navigate complex insurance requirements while securing competitive market solutions.
Denise Griffin
Personal Lines
Denise specializes in personal insurance solutions with a focus on high-net-worth households. Her 12 years of experience ensure clients receive tailored coverage for unique assets and lifestyle needs.
Jon Stahley
Vice President - Claims
Jon leads the claims department with 18 years of experience in insurance dispute resolution. He ensures efficient claim processing while maintaining client advocacy throughout the settlement process.
JoAnn Murray
Vice President of Personal Lines
JoAnn manages personal insurance operations with expertise in condominium and flood insurance. Her 20-year career focuses on creating comprehensive protection plans for residential clients.
Questions
How do I get an insurance quote?
Contact our office directly or complete our online form. Our brokers will assess your needs and provide multiple coverage options within 24 hours.
What commercial insurance types do you handle?
We cover manufacturers, nonprofits, municipalities, special events, and professional liability. Our team specializes in hard-to-place risks and customized business solutions.
Do you offer personal insurance for unique assets?
Yes, we provide specialized coverage for collector cars, watercraft, high-value homes, and umbrella policies exceeding standard limits.
How does your claims process work?
Report claims through our office and receive immediate guidance. Our team coordinates with carriers while keeping you informed at every stage of resolution.
Are you available for urgent insurance needs?
Our brokers respond to urgent requests during business hours. Critical claim matters receive immediate attention through our dedicated claims department.