Your Trusted Insurance Advisor
Located in Tallmadge, Ohio, Jenkins Insurance Agency is a trusted provider of insurance solutions for individuals and businesses in Northeast Ohio. Since 1957, our agency has been dedicated to delivering excellent service and tailored insurance options to meet the unique needs of our clients.
Our Mission
Our mission is to provide a wide spectrum of insurance coverage to ensure the long-term interest of our clients. We strive to provide the broadest packages available with the best possible service. Our priority is always the long-term interest of our clients, and we work closely with our clients to analyze their needs and determine the proper coverage and limits required to meet those needs.
Our Insurance Services
At Jenkins Insurance Agency, we offer a wide range of insurance services, including:
Auto Insurance
We offer excellent companies for all types of auto insurance from standard high liability limit coverage package policies to non-standard/high risk type policies to SR-22 bonds, commercial auto, boats, motor homes, motorcycles, and more. All of our companies are reputable, financially stable A+ to A rated carriers by AM Best Company.
Home Insurance
We offer excellent companies for all types of homes from modest homes to high-value homes, rental properties, renters insurance, condos, and mobile homes. Our companies not only offer the general home coverages but also important extra coverages to protect your property and assets.
Life Insurance
We have individual and group policies available. We represent excellent companies with competitive rates for whole life, universal life, term life, and annuities.
Health Insurance
We offer individual and group policies. Our staff is well-versed in the ever-changing health insurance market as well as the Affordable Care Act (Obamacare) and how to properly quote your policy online to ensure you receive the government subsidy you are eligible to receive.
Business Insurance
We have great markets for almost any type of business, offering excellent coverages to protect your business in any type of situation. From contractors to retail-style stores to restaurants, we have a market or can find a market for just about anything. We also offer commercial auto coverage and surety bonds.
About Us
At Jenkins Insurance Agency, we represent over 30 companies and have an endless array of markets for all types of insurance. Our experienced staff will take the time to analyze your needs, determine the proper coverage and limits required to meet those needs, and place your account with a financially sound independent carrier that best meets your needs.
Get a Quote
To learn more about our insurance services and get a quote, please call us at 330-633-5511 or visit our website. Our experienced agents are available to assist you Monday through Friday from 9:00 am to 5:00 pm.
Contact Us
Jenkins Insurance Agency
885 Southeast Avenue, Tallmadge, OH 44278
Phone: 330-633-5511
Fax: 330-633-3507
Hours: Monday - Friday, 9:00 am - 5:00 pm
Insurance Agency Reviews
The reviews of this insurance agency are mixed, ranging from extremely positive to extremely negative. Some reviewers praise the agency's staff, particularly Josh, Jennifer, and Corey, for their exceptional service, friendly demeanor, and ability to find the right insurance policies. These reviewers appreciate the agency's personalized approach, family-run ownership, and willingness to help.
On the other hand, some reviewers have had a poor experience with the agency. One reviewer, Lisa, wishes she still worked there because of the condescending and rude behavior of Jen. Another reviewer, James, has not received callbacks from the agency after calling twice for a quote. Worse, Lisa Hefling expresses extreme dissatisfaction, claiming that the agency has sold her family a policy that covers only certain types of damage, despite their requests for more comprehensive coverage.
Employees Praised
- Josh, Jennifer, and Corey are highlighted for their exceptional service and ability to find the right insurance policies.
Employees Criticized
- Jen is criticized for being condescending and rude.
Issues with Service
- Some reviewers have not received callbacks from the agency after calling for a quote.
- One reviewer had a negative experience with a policy that did not cover their needs.

Be the first to review Jenkins Insurance Agency.
Write a Review