Business Details
50+ Years
experience
Your Trusted Insurance Partner in Mishawaka, IN
Established in 1959, McCARTHY INSURANCE GROUP has dedicated over six decades to delivering comprehensive insurance solutions across Indiana and Michigan. Our independent agency represents multiple carriers, enabling us to tailor coverage for personal and business needs while prioritizing competitive pricing and individualized service. With offices in Mishawaka, White Pigeon, and Sturgis, we combine deep local knowledge with a commitment to community revitalization through projects like restoring historic buildings. Our team of certified professionals specializes in home, auto, business, life, and health insurance, ensuring clients receive protection that aligns with their unique circumstances.We maintain a mission of quality protection and unparalleled service, exceeding customer expectations through one-stop shopping and customized solutions. By leveraging our expertise in the evolving insurance marketplace, we consistently secure broad coverage at optimal costs for families and businesses alike. Our dedication to excellence extends to financial planning products and ACA-certified health insurance guidance, reflecting our holistic approach to client needs.
Services
Auto Insurance
Business Insurance
Homeowners Insurance
Life & Health Insurance
Renters Insurance
Details
- Year established: 1959
Highlights and features
- 60+ years of experience serving Indiana and Michigan communities
- Independent agency model with multiple carrier partnerships
- Customized insurance solutions for personal and business needs
- Local expertise with three office locations across two states
- Comprehensive coverage including specialty vehicles and health insurance
What people say
Trusted source
Unparalleled service
Knowledgeable team
Competitive pricing
Community commitment
Services
Auto Insurance
Auto insurance protects vehicles against accidents, catastrophic loss, or lawsuits. We provide tailored plans for cars, trucks, vans, motorcycles, and RVs. Our independent agency shops multiple carriers to ensure competitive rates while offering bundled coverage options for maximum savings.
Business Insurance
Customized commercial insurance solutions protect businesses from liability and operational risks. Coverage includes property protection, workers' compensation, general liability, business auto, and excess liability policies. We tailor packages to match specific industry exposures and budget requirements.
Homeowners Insurance
Homeowners insurance safeguards residential properties against catastrophic losses or lawsuits. We offer tailored plans for traditional homes, mobile homes, and watercraft. Bundling multiple policies ensures optimal rate benefits while providing comprehensive asset protection.
Life & Health Insurance
Life insurance policies provide financial security for families through final expense coverage and long-term protection plans. Our ACA-certified agents assist with individual and group health insurance solutions, navigating marketplace exchanges to find affordable coverage options.
Renters Insurance
Renters insurance covers personal belongings against catastrophic losses during tenancy. We create individualized protection plans that safeguard renters' assets while offering bundled policy options to maximize insurance carrier discounts.
People
Connor McCarthy
Owner
As owner of McCARTHY INSURANCE GROUP, Connor McCarthy leads with a commitment to quality protection and unparalleled service. He ensures the agency maintains its founding principles while adapting to modern insurance market demands.
Ann McCarthy
Owner
Co-owner Ann McCarthy contributes to the agency's mission of providing tailored insurance solutions. With decades of industry experience, she helps maintain the company's focus on personalized service and community involvement.
Stacy Vervynckt
Senior Account Executive
Stacy Vervynckt brings extensive commercial insurance expertise to McCARTHY INSURANCE GROUP. As Senior Account Executive, she specializes in creating customized business protection plans that address specific industry risks and regulatory requirements.
Ronda Gebo
Sales & Service Agent
Ronda Gebo serves as a Personal Lines specialist in Mishawaka. Her focus on client education and policy customization helps individuals secure appropriate coverage for homes, vehicles, and personal assets.
Chandra Tavernier
Sales & Service Agent
Based in White Pigeon, Chandra Tavernier provides personalized insurance solutions to southwest Michigan residents. Her approach combines local market knowledge with comprehensive coverage analysis to meet clients' protection needs.
Questions
What types of insurance do you offer?
We provide auto, home, business, life, health, and renters insurance with specialized coverage for vehicles like motorcycles, boats, and RVs.
Do you serve both individuals and businesses?
Yes, we offer personalized insurance solutions for both personal needs and commercial operations across Indiana and Michigan.
How can I get a competitive insurance quote?
Contact us directly through our website or office locations. Our independent agency model allows comparison shopping across multiple carriers for optimal pricing.
Are you locally owned and operated?
Yes, we've been based in Mishawaka since 1959 with additional offices in White Pigeon and Sturgis, serving local communities for over six decades.
Do you offer health insurance solutions?
Yes, our ACA-certified agents provide individual and group health insurance options both on and off the Marketplace Exchange.
Can I bundle multiple insurance policies?
Yes, we recommend bundling policies to maximize savings as insurance companies offer best rates for consolidated coverage.