Business Details
Your Trusted Insurance Partner in Springfield, MO
Fortner Insurance is a family-owned and locally grounded insurance agency based in Springfield, Missouri. With over two hundred years of combined experience, we specialize in providing tailored insurance solutions for churches, businesses, nonprofits, and families across the state. As a trusted Brotherhood Mutual partner, we offer specialized coverage for faith-based organizations, including church property, liability, and mission trip insurance. Our team, led by co-owners Anthony and Nell Gillen, prioritizes personalized service, plain communication, and honest coverage to meet the unique needs of Missouri communities. We work with top-rated carriers like Liberty Mutual and Acuity to ensure clients receive comprehensive protection at competitive rates.Our services extend beyond standard policies to include cyber liability, commercial umbrella coverage, and camp insurance for seasonal and year-round operations. We serve clients statewide, from St. Louis and Kansas City to Branson and Joplin, offering flexible service options through in-person consultations, phone support, and an online self-service portal. Our commitment to building real relationships and long-term trust has made us a preferred insurance partner for Missouri's faith-based communities, educators, and business owners.
Services
Business Insurance
Camp Insurance
Employee Benefits
Life Insurance
Medicare Insurance
Personal Insurance
Church Insurance
Commercial Auto Insurance
Cyber Liability Insurance
Commercial Property Insurance
Highlights and features
- We are a family-owned agency with over 200 years of combined insurance experience.
- We specialize in faith-based insurance solutions as a Brotherhood Mutual partner.
- We offer flexible service options: in-person, phone, or online self-service portal.
- Our team works with top-rated carriers like Liberty Mutual and Acuity.
- We provide specialized coverage for Missouri churches, camps, and Christian schools.
Associations and certifications
- Brotherhood Mutual
What people say
Excellent customer service
Personal attention
Most value and protection
Trusted coverage
Real people and real answers
Services
Business Insurance
Business Insurance protects Missouri organizations against liability claims, property damage, and operational risks. We offer general liability, workers' compensation, commercial auto, and cyber liability policies tailored to industries like retail, nonprofits, and construction. Our team helps businesses meet legal requirements while safeguarding assets.
Camp Insurance
Camp Insurance provides specialized coverage for Christian camps and retreat centers across Missouri. Our policies include property protection for cabins and equipment, liability coverage for campers, and abuse insurance. We partner with Brotherhood Mutual to address risks unique to youth programs and outdoor activities.
Church Insurance
Church Insurance offers comprehensive protection for Missouri congregations, including property damage, pastoral liability, and mission trip coverage. We provide cyber liability policies for online giving platforms and vehicle insurance for church transportation needs. Our expertise ensures alignment with faith-based operations.
Personal Insurance
Personal Insurance covers Missouri families' homes, vehicles, and assets through homeowners, auto, and umbrella policies. We offer flood insurance for riverfront properties and boat coverage for lake activities. Bundling options help clients save on combined home and auto protection.
Employee Benefits
Employee Benefits help Missouri employers design competitive health, dental, and life insurance packages. We assist businesses in selecting cost-effective group plans that attract talent while meeting regulatory requirements. Our solutions cater to small and mid-sized organizations.
People
Anthony Gillen
Co-Owner
Anthony Gillen co-leads Fortner Insurance with a focus on personalized service and community engagement. He specializes in faith-based insurance solutions and maintains direct client relationships for business and church policies.
Nell Gillen
Co-Owner
Nell Gillen co-owns Fortner Insurance and oversees client experience with emphasis on family and personal insurance. She ensures policies meet Missouri families' needs while maintaining the agency's commitment to honest coverage.
Questions
What insurance does a Missouri business need?
Most businesses require general liability and property coverage. Additional policies like workers' comp or cyber liability depend on industry-specific risks and legal requirements.
Do Missouri churches need separate vehicle insurance?
Yes, church-owned vehicles require specialized commercial auto insurance to cover transportation for events, youth trips, and outreach programs.
Is flood insurance required in Missouri?
Standard home policies don't cover floods. Separate flood insurance is recommended for properties near rivers, creeks, or low-lying areas in Missouri.
Can I bundle home and auto insurance?
Yes, bundling home and auto insurance often provides cost savings and simplified billing through multiple carrier options.
What camp insurance coverage is essential?
Essential camp insurance includes property coverage, general liability, camper accident protection, and abuse coverage for youth programs.
Do Missouri schools need D&O insurance?
Yes, directors and officers (D&O) insurance protects school leadership from personal liability for decisions made on behalf of educational institutions.