Website Call now
Website
Call

Experience the Difference of Personalized Service

At Elaine Jennings Insurance Agency, we are proud to be an award-winning Independent Insurance Agency serving the people of Cape Coral, Fort Myers, and all of Southwest Florida. As a Trusted Choice Agent and a member of the Florida Association of Insurance Agents, we specialize in providing affordable home insurance, condo insurance, renter's insurance, auto insurance, boat and watercraft insurance, as well as life and health insurance.

Our Promise of Service Excellence

We believe in hometown service and hold ourselves to a higher standard. When you work with us, you can expect:

  • We will listen to your needs and provide you with options, so you can make an informed decision that's best for your specific situation.
  • We will always do our best to save you money while offering you the best coverage.
  • We believe in quality customer service, and will promptly return your calls.

Why Choose an Independent Agent?

Independent Insurance Agents, like Elaine Jennings, act as your trusted advisor with access to numerous quality insurance companies. We work hard to find the best insurance suited for your specific needs. Our goal is to present you with options and give you the best combination of value, coverage, and service.

How We Differ

At Elaine Jennings Insurance Agency, we're in the people business first and the insurance business second. We still believe in things like honesty, integrity, professionalism, and going the extra mile for our customers. We're not here to push a certain insurance product on you; instead, we'll take the time to listen to your needs and educate you on the options available.

Our Services

We offer a full range of insurance services, including:

  • Home Owners Insurance
  • Condo Insurance
  • Renter's Insurance
  • Auto Insurance
  • Boat and Watercraft Insurance
  • Life and Health Insurance

Testimonials

Don't just take our word for it! Our clients have praised us for our friendly, thorough, and professional service. Here's what some of them have to say:

  • "Elaine is the best!. She took her time and explained everything in great detail." - Mike, Cape Coral, FL
  • "Called for a quote and Elaine was very quick to get a set of numbers and detail needed to switch from my previous carrier. She saved me a thousand dollars and has been great in getting me what was needed for coverage." - Robert, Cape Coral, Florida

Get in Touch

Call us today at 239-540-4200 to experience the difference it makes when you work with an agent who truly cares about your needs.

Reviews
Positive: Overall, reviewers praised Elaine Jennings Insurance Agency for its professionalism, exceptional service, attention to detail, and consistency.
Negative: However, C. Bamboo's review highlights a disappointing and frustrating experience with the agency's customer service.

Professionalism and Service

Elaine Jennings Insurance Agency is known for its professionalism and exceptional service. According to several reviewers, Elaine is a wonderful insurance agent who takes pride in her work. Mary Fineberg, who recently moved to Florida and asked a neighbor for insurance recommendations, was impressed by Elaine's professional demeanor and friendly attitude. Cassandra Ginley, who has been working with Elaine for years, also praised Elaine's ability to save her money and provide great coverage.

Attention to Detail and Follow-Through

Elaine's agency is also praised for its attention to detail and follow-through. JoAnne Linsenbach, who has worked with Elaine for years, reported that Elaine always returns calls quickly, even when she's very busy. Similarly, Michael Ginley, who has also been with Elaine for years, mentioned that Elaine takes good care of him and would recommend her to anyone.

Consistency and Quality

Daniel Seckman's review highlighted the agency's consistency and quality, stating that it's 100% 5-star quality, including all the bells and whistles. Cassandra Ginley's second review also praised the agency's consistency, stating that Elaine has always taken good care of her and would highly recommend her to all their friends.

Disappointment and Frustration

Unfortunately, C. Bamboo's review highlights a negative experience with the agency. He sold his house in March and attempted to cancel his insurance, but the agency refused to answer his phone calls or respond to his faxes. As a result, he had to go directly to Southern Fidelity to cancel his policy and is still waiting for his refund check six months later.

Review Elaine Jennings Insurance

Be the first to review Elaine Jennings Insurance.

Write a Review