Local. Trusted. Protection!
Savage-McVicker Insurance, Inc. is a third-generation, family-owned independent insurance agency, proud to provide personal and commercial insurance solutions to individuals, families, and businesses for over six decades. With roots dating back to 1960, our company was founded by James McVicker Sr., who instilled our corporate culture with his philosophy of "looking for the best in others and giving them the best that you have." This principle guides our approach to customer service, ensuring that each client receives tailored coverage that meets their unique needs.
Our Mission
As local insurance professionals, we take pride in building long-term relationships with our clients, providing personalized service, and delivering innovative insurance solutions. We strive to be the go-to insurance partner for individuals and businesses seeking reliable protection. Our dedicated team is committed to understanding your specific needs, offering expert guidance, and securing the best possible coverage for your cherished assets.
Our Services
Our comprehensive suite of insurance services includes:
- Personal Insurance: Protect your loved ones with our extensive range of personal insurance options, covering your home, auto, life, and more.
- Business & Commercial Insurance: Safeguard your business operations and assets with our commercial insurance solutions, designed to address your unique industry and risk profile.
- Surety Bonds: Guarantee compliance with regulations and contracts with our bond insurance services.
- Financial Benefits & Life: Plan for the future with our life insurance and financial planning strategies.
Meet Our Team
Our team is comprised of experienced insurance professionals who are dedicated to providing exceptional service. We take pride in developing personal relationships with our clients, understanding their unique needs, and delivering tailored insurance solutions. Get to know our team members and learn about their areas of expertise.
Overall Experience
The reviews for Savage-McVicker Insurance are overwhelmingly positive, with most reviewers praising the company's excellent service, professionalism, and attention to detail. Many reviewers have been with the company for years and express their satisfaction with the service they have received.
Positive Reviews
Reviewers have praised the company's agents, including Diana, Kelly, Dan, and Amber, for being extremely helpful, responsive, and professional. Many have mentioned that their agents have gone above and beyond to ensure that their insurance needs are met, and that they have received competitive rates.
Increased Competition
However, one reviewer expressed their dissatisfaction with the company's handling of their business after their long-time agent left. They claimed that the new agent was unable to answer basic insurance questions and seemed uninterested in doing anything that required effort.
Consistency Issues
Another reviewer mentioned that after a new agent was assigned to them, they experienced difficulties in getting their policy changed. They were told to wait for an email from Progressive, which didn't arrive, and had to call Progressive directly to get the issue resolved.

Be the first to review Savagemcvicker Insurance.
Write a Review