Business Details
17 Years
experience
Your Trusted Insurance Partner in St. Joseph, MO
McKay Insurance Services is an independent brokerage dedicated to guiding clients through the complexities of Medicare and other insurance solutions. Founded in 2009 by Deborah McKay, our agency specializes in educating, enrolling, and supporting individuals transitioning to Medicare. Our team of licensed professionals, including Tim McKay, Gabrielle Flugrad, and Jack McKay, brings decades of combined experience in health, life, and supplemental insurance.We prioritize personalized service, offering face-to-face consultations to clarify coverage options, compare plans, and secure competitive rates. As a broker, we work with multiple carriers to ensure clients receive tailored solutions that meet their unique needs. Our commitment to transparency, client education, and ethical practices has earned us a trusted reputation in St. Joseph, Missouri, and surrounding regions.
Services
Medicare Supplements
Medicare Advantage Plans
Prescription Drug Plans
Employer Group Insurance
Affordable Care Act Plans
Short-Term Health Insurance
Travel Health Insurance
Vision/Dental Plans
Life Insurance
Aflac Policies
Details
- Year established: 2009
Highlights and features
- We offer 15+ years of Medicare insurance expertise with personalized guidance.
- Our independent brokerage provides access to multiple carriers and competitive rates.
- We prioritize face-to-face consultations to ensure clear understanding of coverage options.
- Our team includes licensed agents with specialized knowledge in health and life insurance.
- We serve clients in Missouri, Iowa, Illinois, and Kansas with localized expertise.
What people say
Sincere thanks for your time
Strongly recommend McKay Insurance
Feels like home
Best insurance you could ask for
Never rushed or pressured
Services
Medicare Supplements
Medicare Supplement plans help cover out-of-pocket costs like deductibles and copays for Original Medicare. We offer personalized comparisons between Plan G, Plan N, and other options to find the best fit for your health needs and budget. Our team guides you through enrollment and underwriting processes.
Medicare Advantage Plans
These all-in-one alternatives to Original Medicare include prescription drug coverage, dental, vision, and wellness benefits. We explain plan networks, out-of-pocket maximums, and copay structures to help you choose coverage that aligns with your healthcare usage patterns and financial goals.
Prescription Drug Plans
We help you select Part D plans that cover your specific medications at the lowest cost. Our process includes analyzing your prescriptions using Medicare.gov tools and explaining formulary tiers, coverage gaps, and premium variations between carriers.
Affordable Care Act Plans
We provide ACA-compliant individual and family health insurance options with subsidies. Our services include plan comparisons, enrollment assistance, and explanations of essential health benefits, preventive care coverage, and network providers.
Life Insurance
We offer term and whole life insurance policies, including final expense coverage to protect your family's financial future. Our team compares rates from multiple carriers and explains policy features like death benefits, premium structures, and underwriting requirements.
People
Deborah McKay
Owner
Founder of McKay Insurance Services with 15+ years in health insurance. Specializes in Medicare transitions, offering personalized guidance to help clients understand coverage options and secure competitive rates.
Tim McKay
CAO/Agent
Former IT professional turned insurance agent. Focuses on group insurance, ACA plans, and Medicare solutions. Brings technical expertise to simplify complex insurance products for clients.
Gabrielle Flugrad
Licensed Agent
Joined the team after eight years at FedEx Express. Specializes in Medicare Part A/B, drug plans, and ACA coverage. Prioritizes building trust through personalized service and clear communication.
Jack McKay
Licensed Agent
Former Air Force member with expertise in individual/group health insurance and life insurance. Focuses on helping clients find affordable coverage that matches their unique circumstances and family needs.
Questions
What Medicare plans do you offer?
We provide Medicare Supplements, Advantage Plans, Prescription Drug Plans, and Hospital Indemnity options to meet diverse healthcare needs.
Can I change Medicare plans outside enrollment periods?
Yes, if you qualify for a Special Enrollment Period or meet Missouri's 30-day policy change window without underwriting.
Do you help with employer group insurance?
Yes, we assist employers with group health insurance quotes, employee education, and payroll integration support.
What areas do you serve?
We operate in Missouri, Iowa, Illinois, and Kansas, with expertise in regional insurance requirements.