Empowering Our Community, One Relationship at a Time.
At the Cotgreave Insurance Agency, we are dedicated to providing exceptional customer service and delivering the best insurance solutions to our clients. With over 30 years of experience, we have established ourselves as a leading insurance agency in the tri-state area, serving commercial and individual clients with their insurance needs.
Our Mission and Values
Our mission is to provide superior customer service while acting with honesty and integrity. We value our clients and employees, and we strive to build long-term relationships with them. We believe that our clients deserve individualized attention and superior customer service at a fair price.
Our Services
We offer a wide range of insurance services to our clients, including:
- Home Insurance: We provide insurance solutions for your home, including liability coverage, dwelling coverage, and personal property coverage.
- Auto Insurance: Our auto insurance policies provide financial protection in the event of an accident, covering damages, medical expenses, and other related costs.
- Business Insurance: We offer customized insurance solutions for businesses of all sizes, including coverage for property, liability, and business interruption.
- Life and Annuity: Our life insurance policies provide financial security for your loved ones in the event of your passing, while our annuity products provide a steady income stream in retirement.
- Group Benefits: We offer a range of group benefit options, including health, dental, and vision plans, to help employers provide valuable benefits to their employees.
- Specialty Programs: Our industry-specific insurance programs are designed to meet the unique needs of businesses in various sectors, such as healthcare, technology, and finance.
Our Team
At the Cotgreave Insurance Agency, we are proud to have a talented and dedicated team of insurance professionals who are committed to providing exceptional service to our clients. Our management team includes experienced leaders who have many years of experience in the insurance industry.
Our Carriers
We represent multiple insurance carriers, which allows us to offer a wide range of insurance products and services to our clients. Our carriers include leading insurance companies that are known for their financial strength, stability, and customer service.
Get a Quote
We are committed to helping our clients get the best possible insurance coverage at the most competitive rate. To get a quote, please contact us today to speak with one of our knowledgeable insurance professionals.
Hours and Location
Our office is located in Ronkonkoma, New York, and we are open Monday through Friday from 8:30 am to 5:00 pm. You can visit us in person or contact us by phone or email to request a consultation.
Summary of Reviews
Positive Experiences
Reviews praise the excellent service provided by individual staff members, including Sheldon, Chris O, Kristin, Tracy, Ken Claffie, and Gerard. They appreciate the personalized attention, professionalism, and ability to find the right coverage at a competitive price.
Negative Experiences
On the other hand, some reviewers express frustration and disappointment with their experiences. Maria Napolitano is accused of canceling an insurance policy without notice, and Cotgreave Insurance is blamed for causing a lapse in insurance coverage due to failure to verify payment with a mortgage company.
Staff Performance
Some staff members, such as Maria Napolitano, are criticized for their poor service, while others, like Sheldon, Chris O, Kristin, Tracy, Ken Claffie, and Gerard, are praised for their exceptional service and ability to resolve issues efficiently.
Company Performance
Cotgreave Insurance is praised for its ability to provide top-tier coverage at competitive prices, but it is also criticized for its failure to communicate effectively with customers, leading to issues with policy cancellations and lapses in coverage.
Be the first to review Cotgreave Insurance.
Write a Review
