Call Now
Website
Call
Business Details
32 Years
experience
Your Trusted Insurance Agency Network Partner
Founded in 1994, Smart Choice has been dedicated to empowering independent insurance agents through unparalleled access to top-rated markets, comprehensive product training, and robust sales and marketing support. Our no-fee program uniquely positions agents to gain immediate appointments with over 100 carriers within 24 hours through our Express Markets team. With a network of 10,000+ agencies and $12 billion in written premiums collectively, we prioritize our partners' success by offering low production requirements, competitive commissions, and 100% book ownership. Our team of industry experts provides personalized guidance, ensuring agents can efficiently place clients while maintaining full control of their business.

Recognized by Inc. Magazine as a Power Partner, we combine decades of experience with innovative solutions to help agents grow sustainably. Our commitment to transparency, ethical practices, and eliminating barriers like upfront fees has made us the fastest-growing agency network in the nation. By fostering direct carrier relationships and offering tools like automated life insurance platforms, we enable agents to focus on client satisfaction while achieving financial milestones. Our track record of helping agencies reach commission caps, qualify for profit sharing, and expand their operations underscores our role as a trusted partner in the insurance industry.
Services
Commercial Insurance Personal Insurance Life Insurance Excess & Surplus Lines Agency Support Services
Details
  • Year established: 1994
Highlights and features
  • We offer no fees to join or maintain membership in our program
  • We provide access to over 100 carriers including Travelers, Nationwide, and Allstate
  • Our agents can earn 100% of commissions with low production requirements
  • We deliver immediate carrier appointments within 24 hours through Express Markets
  • Our dedicated team provides personalized support and market expertise
What people say
Freedom to succeed No fees required Quick carrier appointments 100% commission potential Personalized support
Services
Commercial Insurance
Smart Choice provides access to top commercial carriers like Travelers and Nationwide. Our program helps agencies place business through sub-appointments or in-house underwriting. Agents benefit from lower volume commitments and competitive commissions while maintaining full book ownership.
Personal Insurance
Our personal lines program connects agents with major carriers through managed carrier relationships. The network offers 100% book ownership, competitive commissions, and access to high-net-worth insurance solutions for home, auto, and specialty assets.
Life Insurance
Smart Choice Life provides access to respected carriers and automated platforms for life, LTC, and annuities. Our program includes instant issue policies, online rating tools, and dedicated support for efficient policy placement and client service.
Excess & Surplus Lines
Express Markets offers access to 35+ E&S carriers with immediate approval capabilities. Agents earn 100% commissions without fees or production requirements, with direct appointment options for hard-to-place risks through our specialty carrier network.
Agency Support Services
We provide discounted E&O insurance, agency software solutions, lead sourcing, continuing education, and financing options. Our business solutions center offers resources to help agencies operate efficiently and grow sustainably.
People
Douglas S. Witcher
Founder and Chairman of the Board
Founder of Smart Choice with over 30 years of insurance industry experience. Recognized for creating a network that prioritizes agent success through no-fee access to carriers and innovative business solutions.
Andrew Caldwell
Chief Executive Officer
Brings extensive insurance leadership experience to drive Smart Choice's strategic growth. Focused on expanding carrier partnerships and enhancing digital solutions for agency partners.
Jef Morgan
Senior Vice President of InsurTech
Leads InsurTech initiatives with a focus on operational excellence and expanding carrier partnerships. Previously held leadership roles in insurance technology innovation.
Todd Alexanderson
State Director
Provides localized support to agents with deep carrier connections. Known for exceptional availability and problem-solving capabilities in placing complex risks.
Chris Reisdorf
Territory Manager
Offers hands-on support to agents without micromanagement. Recognized for expertise in carrier relationships and commitment to agent success through personalized guidance.
Questions
How do I join Smart Choice as an independent agent?
Complete our online application to gain immediate access to our network of 100+ carriers with no fees or long-term commitments.
What insurance markets does Smart Choice provide access to?
We offer commercial, personal, life, and excess/surplus lines through partnerships with top-rated carriers nationwide.
Are there fees associated with Smart Choice membership?
No fees are required to join or maintain membership in our program, and we don't charge for carrier appointments.
How does Smart Choice's commission structure work?
Agents earn competitive commissions with potential for 100% payout after meeting low production thresholds, with no ongoing fees.
What support resources are available to members?
We provide dedicated underwriting assistance, product training, marketing support, and access to our business solutions center.