Business Details
50+ Years
experience
Your Trusted Insurance Partner in Mansfield, OH
Since 1939, Hitchman Insurance Agency has provided advanced and dependable insurance solutions to individuals and businesses. As a fourth-generation, family-owned agency, we combine old-fashioned service with modern technology to deliver quality, personalized coverage. Our team of experienced agents brings over 90 years of combined expertise, specializing in placing unique risks and offering tailored policies through multiple carriers. We prioritize client needs, ensuring assets are protected with precision and care. Our reputation as one of Ohio's most trusted agencies is built on decades of reliability, competitive rates, and a commitment to innovation.Clients praise our fast, easy, and professional service, with testimonials highlighting exceptional customer support and value-driven solutions. We serve Mansfield and surrounding areas, offering comprehensive insurance products including auto, home, business, farm, and specialty policies. Our local knowledge and dedication to client satisfaction make us a preferred choice for insurance needs. We guarantee transparency, no hidden fees, and personalized guidance to help clients navigate coverage options. With a legacy of excellence spanning over 80 years, we remain dedicated to serving our community with integrity and expertise.
Services
Auto Insurance
Boat Insurance
Business Insurance
Home Insurance
Life & Health Insurance
Farm Insurance
Flood Insurance
Surety Bonds
Umbrella Policies
Classic Car Insurance
Details
- Year established: 1939
Highlights and features
- Family-owned since 1939 with fourth-generation expertise
- Over 90 years of combined experience among agents
- Competitive rates through multiple insurance carriers
- Specialize in placing unique and hard-to-place risks
- Personalized service with local market expertise
What people say
Great service
Best price
Quick claim processing
Friendly and helpful
Trusted agency
Services
Auto Insurance
We provide comprehensive auto insurance solutions with options like roadside assistance, zero deductible glass repair, rental reimbursement, and SR-22 policies. Our agents help clients access multi-car, safe driver, and good student discounts while ensuring proper coverage. With multiple carrier options, we guarantee competitive rates tailored to individual driving needs.
Business Insurance
Our business insurance offers general liability, professional liability, business owner policies, and surety bonds for contractors, plumbers, electricians, and various industries. We provide tailored coverage including tool protection, loss of income during repairs, and specialized endorsements. Our experienced agents help businesses navigate complex requirements and secure comprehensive protection.
Home Insurance
We offer home insurance with enhanced protections including service line coverage, equipment breakdown protection, water damage coverage, and scheduled item protection for valuables. Our policies address modern risks while maintaining competitive pricing through multiple carriers. Agents help homeowners understand coverage options and secure appropriate protection levels.
Boat Insurance
Our boat insurance includes on-water towing, full replacement cost, mechanical breakdown coverage, and water sports protection. We provide comprehensive marine insurance with customizable endorsements to protect various watercraft types. Agents work with clients to ensure proper coverage for recreational boating needs.
Life & Health Insurance
We offer life and health insurance solutions to protect clients' financial futures. Our agents help individuals select appropriate coverage levels and policy types to meet their specific needs. With access to multiple carriers, we provide competitive options for long-term security planning.
People
James R. Hitchman
Agent
Fourth-generation insurance professional with deep local expertise, providing personalized coverage solutions and maintaining the family agency's legacy of excellence.
Jamie D. Hitchman
Agent
Experienced insurance agent committed to helping clients protect their assets with tailored policies and competitive rates through multiple carriers.
Derek T. Mills
Agent
Professional insurance agent with extensive experience in risk assessment and policy customization to meet diverse client needs.
Jenna L. Schroeder
Agent
Dedicated insurance professional focused on delivering personalized service and comprehensive coverage options to residential and commercial clients.
Kristen A. Wendling
Agent
Experienced team member providing expert guidance on insurance solutions, with a focus on client education and satisfaction.
Questions
What types of insurance do you offer?
We offer auto, boat, home, business, farm, life, health, flood, surety bonds, umbrella policies, and classic car insurance.
How long have you been in business?
Hitchman Insurance Agency has served clients since 1939, maintaining family ownership across four generations.
Do you offer competitive rates?
Yes, we provide competitive rates through multiple carriers while maintaining personalized service and local expertise.
What payment options are available?
We accept in-office payments and online payments for your convenience.
