Let OUR family protect YOUR family and business.
At Hostetler Insurance Agency, we pride ourselves on being a full-service independent insurance agency with over 120 years of combined insurance experience and expertise. Our team of insurance professionals is dedicated to providing personalized service to our clients, helping them navigate the complex world of insurance. As an independent agency, we have the ability to offer insurance products from national, regional, and local carriers, allowing us to tailor our services to meet the unique needs of our clients.
Our Mission
As a family-owned agency, we understand the importance of protecting not only your family but also your business. At Hostetler Insurance Agency, our mission is to provide exceptional insurance services while fostering a culture of integrity, trust, and commitment to our clients. Whether you are an individual, business, or entrepreneur, we are committed to providing personalized insurance solutions that meet your specific needs.
Insurance Products
At Hostetler Insurance Agency, we understand that every individual and business is unique, which is why we offer a wide range of insurance products to cater to your specific needs. Our insurance products include:
- Auto Insurance: From personal to collector's vehicles, we have the expertise to provide the right coverage for you.
- Home Insurance: Whether you own a residence, condo, or rental property, we can help you secure the right coverage.
- Commercial Business Insurance: We understand that no two businesses are alike, and our experienced staff will tailor a package to protect your business and give you peace of mind.
- Life Insurance: Choose from a range of life insurance options, including term, whole, and universal life insurance.
Auto Insurance
At Hostetler Insurance Agency, we understand the importance of having adequate auto insurance coverage. Our team of experts can help you navigate the complex world of auto insurance, providing personalized coverage options to suit your needs. With a range of coverage options, including liability, collision, comprehensive, and additional expense coverage, we can help you drive with confidence knowing that you are well-protected.
Commercial Business Insurance
At Hostetler Insurance Agency, we recognize that every business is unique, and that's why we offer a range of commercial insurance products to meet the specific needs of your business. Our experienced staff will work with you to tailor a package that covers your business and provides peace of mind.
Contact Us
At Hostetler Insurance Agency, we are committed to providing exceptional service to our clients. If you have any questions or need assistance with your insurance needs, please do not hesitate to contact us. Our team of experts is here to help you navigate the complex world of insurance and provide personalized solutions to meet your unique needs.
Overall Experience
The insurance agency Hostetler Insurance Agency has received overwhelmingly positive reviews from its clients. The majority of the reviewers have had a great experience with the agency, praising the friendly and helpful staff, prompt service, and competitive rates.
Customer Service
Reviewers have commended the agency for its fast and attentive customer service. Many have mentioned that the agents are quick to respond to questions and concerns, making the insurance process smooth and stress-free. Some have even highlighted specific agents, such as Mike, who went above and beyond to help customers.
Insurance Services
The agency has been praised for its ability to find competitive rates and offer a variety of insurance options. Reviewers have mentioned that the agents helped them find the best coverage for their needs, and that the agency is always willing to shop around for the best deals.
Claims Handling
Some reviewers have had to file claims, and they have praised the agency for making the process easy and hassle-free. One reviewer mentioned that filing a claim was "rediculously easy" and that the agency was helpful and efficient.
Negative Feedback
One reviewer, St, expressed dissatisfaction with the agency's pricing. They mentioned that the quote provided over the phone was not what they were expecting, and that the price doubled after they purchased the truck. Another reviewer, Dennis Rak, mentioned that they had to transfer several times to get to a person who could help with a question.

Be the first to review Hostetler Insurance Agency.
Write a Review