Your Peace of Mind is Our Priority
At Riley & Riley Insurance Services, we are committed to serving the Central Coast with honesty, support, and satisfaction. As a family-owned and operated business, we have been serving this community for over 25 years. While our name may be new, our commitment to excellence and customer service remains unchanged.
Our Story
Riley & Riley Insurance Services is the culmination of a long tradition of family ownership and operation. Campbell-Taylor Insurance, our parent company, has been owned and operated by our family for over 25 years. We are proud to continue this legacy of commitment to our community and to our customers.
Our Mission
At Riley & Riley Insurance Services, we are dedicated to providing our customers with a wide range of insurance services. Whether you're a business owner, individual, or family, we have the expertise and knowledge to help you navigate the complexities of insurance. Our mission is to provide our customers with the best possible coverage at a fair price, while also providing exceptional customer service.
Our Services
We offer a wide range of insurance services, including:
Business Insurance
- Commercial Auto Insurance
- Business Liability Insurance
- Worker's Compensation Insurance
Personal Insurance
- Life Insurance
- Home Owner's Insurance
- Health Insurance
Personalized Service
At Riley & Riley Insurance Services, we understand that every customer is unique, with their own set of needs and circumstances. That's why we take the time to get to know each of our customers, to understand their specific insurance needs and goals. We are committed to providing personalized service and tailored solutions that meet the unique needs of each of our customers.
About Our Team
At Riley & Riley Insurance Services, we pride ourselves on our team's expertise and dedication to exceptional customer service. Our team includes:
- Tyler Riley: Tyler has been in the insurance industry for over 15 years and is a licensed Property and Casualty Agent. He is also working on his Certified Insurance Counselor's (CIC) designation.
- Susan Riley: Susan has been working in the insurance field for over 30 years, including agency management, sales, and marketing. She and her husband Joel have owned and operated an insurance consulting business for the past 23 years.
What Our Customers Say
Don't just take our word for it! Here's what some of our satisfied customers have to say:
- "Very happy with the new office location and the new staff is friendly, helpful, and very welcoming. Thank you." - Mr. & Mrs. Snyder
- "We received fast, friendly service from the amazing staff at R&R, after just a few simple questions, they were able to save us big money on the right policies." - Randall
- "This is the best service I have ever had in the 84 years I've had to have insurance." - Beth Adams
- "Keep up the great work, thanks for everything!" - Kasey Fox
- "You guys do an awesome job on all of my insurance needs!" - Sherrie Flores
Request a Quote
Ready to get started? Request a quote today and let us help you find the perfect insurance solution for your needs.
Contact Information
1164 E Grand Ave. Arroyo Grande, CA 93420
P | 805.481.0664
F | 805.481.3532
Overview of Riley & Riley Insurance Agency
Exceptional Customer Service
The Riley & Riley Insurance Agency is praised for its exceptional customer service, with many reviewers praising the agency's staff for going above and beyond to provide smooth and easy transactions.
Knowledgeable Agents
Tyler Riley, in particular, is commended for his knowledge, especially when it comes to business insurance. Other agents, such as Lindee and Susan, are also mentioned for their expertise and helpfulness.
Quick Response Times
Reviewers appreciate the agency's prompt response times, with many noting that they receive quick answers to their questions and concerns.
Professionalism and Friendly Service
The agency is described as professional, friendly, and responsive, with reviewers feeling valued and appreciated as clients.
Range of Insurance Services
Riley & Riley offers a range of insurance services, including home, auto, business, and boat insurance, making it a one-stop shop for many clients.

Be the first to review Riley & Riley Insurance.
Write a Review