Hoyt-Costello Insurance Agency

Our Story

At Costello Insurance Agency, we pride ourselves on being a family-run business since 1954. With over 50 years of experience, we have built a reputation for providing friendly, dependable service to our customers in Massachusetts and New Hampshire. Our team of caring and highly experienced insurance professionals have logged over 100 years in the insurance business, and we are dedicated to getting our customers the best product at the best price.

Our Commitment

As a full-service insurance agency, we offer a wide range of personal and commercial insurance products, including auto, homeowner, renter, condo, and business owner's insurance. We understand that every customer's needs are unique, which is why we take the time to get to know our customers and provide personalized service. Our goal is to help our customers feel confident and protected in their insurance choices.

Our Advantage

Our commitment to customer service is unparalleled. We work directly with over 100 insurance companies, including our elite core insurer partners who share our values of integrity, honesty, and business principles. We take the time to understand our customers' specific needs and provide guidance on the best insurance options for their individual circumstances. Our team of experts is always available to answer questions, provide quotes, and help with claims.

Our Locations

We have two convenient locations: our flagship office in Bradford, Massachusetts, and our branch office in Exeter, New Hampshire. Our offices are easily accessible, and our friendly staff are always happy to welcome customers.

Our Team

Our team of insurance professionals is comprised of caring and highly experienced individuals who have decades of combined insurance experience. We take pride in our ability to build long-lasting relationships with our customers, many of whom have been with us for 20, 30, or even 40 years.

Our Mission

Our mission is simple: to provide the best insurance products and service to our customers at the best price. We believe that insurance should be a partnership between the customer and the insurance agency. We take the time to listen, educate, and guide our customers to make informed insurance decisions.