Mahaffey / Betts Agency

Welcome to Mahaffey/Betts Agency, Inc., a family-owned, locally-operated, independent insurance and real estate agency serving individuals, families, and businesses throughout Central Illinois. We live and work in a culture where technology offers us tremendous opportunities and a fast pace. While this is great, sometimes it becomes too easy to lose touch and connection with people. We make good use of the advantages available through technology, but believe in building long-term relationships. We treat you as friends, with respect, honesty, and integrity.

Our family has made our home in and served central Illinois' insurance needs since 1947! We know the local contractors, repair shops, schools, doctors, and more. Our services include auto insurance, business insurance, farm insurance, home insurance, life insurance, recreational vehicles, and much more.

Our Expertise and Commitment

At Mahaffey/Betts Agency, Inc., we are dedicated to providing quality insurance products that keep you protected. We are independent agents with only the customer in mind! Our exceptional staff has the skill and know-how to recommend the personal or business insurance that may be best for you. Whether you need business insurance or personal insurance, we will customize a plan to suit your needs.

Our Services

We can create customized insurance solutions to help guarantee the complete protection of your business. From workers' compensation coverage to general liability, we have the products that will help enhance your business while protecting its vital assets. Our personal coverage includes home, auto, high-risk auto, motorcycles, boats, recreational vehicles, snowmobiles, personal umbrella, life insurance, and much more.

Our Values

To us, people and relationships still matter! We believe in building long-term relationships and treating you as friends, with respect, honesty, and integrity. We understand that every individual and business has unique needs, and we are committed to providing personalized insurance solutions that cater to those needs.

Our History

Established in 1947, Mahaffey/Betts Agency, Inc. has proudly provided comprehensive insurance solutions throughout Illinois. With more than seventy years of service supplying the insurance needs of individuals, families, and businesses, we are a trusted source for home insurance, auto insurance, renters insurance, and more. Whether you need to insure a car or a car dealership, we have an insurance solution for you.