Call Now
Website
Call
Business Details
39 Years
experience
Your Trusted Insurance Partner in Madison, SD
First Madison Insurance has been a trusted name in the insurance industry since 1987, when Eldon Red Beukelman acquired the agency from First Bank. Over the years, the business transitioned through dedicated ownership, including Roger and Rose Stordahl, who maintained its family-oriented ethos before passing it to Greg and Tammy Fender in 2014. In 2023, the torch was carried forward by Gerrit Juffer, Jeff Juffer, and Lyubov Blyshchik, ensuring continuity in personalized service. As an independent agency, we are proud members of the Independent Insurance Agents of South Dakota, Independent Insurance Agents of America (Big I), and Trusted Choice, affiliations that underscore our commitment to excellence. Our team of licensed professionals brings decades of combined experience, specializing in tailored insurance solutions for individuals and businesses across eight states.

We prioritize client relationships, offering comprehensive coverage through partnerships with over a dozen insurance companies. Our dedication to continuous professional development ensures we remain at the forefront of industry trends, providing expert guidance and peace of mind. With office hours from 8 AM to 5 PM Monday through Friday and after-hours appointments available, we strive to meet the needs of our community with flexibility and care. Our mission remains rooted in protecting what matters most to our clients, combining local expertise with national resources to deliver reliable, client-centric solutions.
Services
Auto Insurance Homeowners Insurance Commercial Auto Flood Insurance Life Insurance Renters Insurance General Liability Workers Compensation Recreational Vehicle Insurance Specialty Insurance
Details
  • Year established: 1987
Highlights and features
  • We offer over 30 years of family-owned, client-focused service.
  • Our team includes licensed agents with expertise in personal and commercial lines.
  • We provide tailored insurance solutions through partnerships with 12+ carriers.
  • Our local knowledge ensures policies meet South Dakota's unique needs.
  • We maintain affiliations with industry leaders like Trusted Choice and Big I.
Services
Auto Insurance
Auto insurance policies protect drivers with liability, collision, and comprehensive coverage tailored to individual needs. Our agents help clients navigate options for personal and commercial vehicles, ensuring compliance with state requirements while offering customizable add-ons. With access to multiple carriers, we secure competitive rates and personalized service for every client.
Homeowners Insurance
Homeowners insurance safeguards property against damage, theft, and liability claims. We offer policies covering structural repairs, personal belongings, and additional living expenses during displacement. Our team specializes in risk assessment for South Dakota's climate, ensuring policies address regional concerns like severe weather. Clients benefit from claims support and policy adjustments as needs evolve.
Commercial Auto
Commercial auto insurance covers company-owned vehicles used for business operations. Policies include liability protection, physical damage coverage, and uninsured motorist provisions. Our agents work with industries ranging from agriculture to transportation, tailoring policies to fleet size and risk exposure. We also assist with compliance documentation and risk management strategies for businesses.
Workers Compensation
Workers' compensation insurance provides wage replacement and medical benefits for employees injured on the job. We help businesses meet state mandates while managing claims efficiently to minimize disruptions. Our partnerships with carriers specializing in high-risk industries ensure competitive pricing and dedicated claims handling for employers across multiple sectors.
Specialty Insurance
Specialty insurance addresses niche risks not covered by standard policies, including collector cars, fine arts, and recreational vehicles. Our agents assess unique assets to create customized policies that reflect their value and usage. We serve clients with specialized needs through underwriters experienced in non-traditional insurance products, ensuring comprehensive protection for valuable possessions.
People
Lyubov Blyshchik
Owner/Agent
Lyubov 'Luba' Blyshchik brings 13+ years of insurance expertise to First Madison Insurance, managing personal and commercial lines while overseeing daily operations. She prioritizes client relationships and continuous learning to deliver tailored solutions. Outside work, she enjoys gardening, woodworking, and family time.
Tammy Marko
Insurance Agent
Tammy Marko specializes in personal lines insurance with three years of experience, guiding clients through coverage options with a friendly, detail-oriented approach. She enjoys fishing, reading, and crafting outside her role at the agency.
Zachery Swope
Commercial Agent
Zachery Swope manages commercial insurance policies and client inquiries with two years of experience in business coverage solutions. His interests include photography and 3D printing, complementing his analytical approach to risk management.
Tracy Booze
Bookkeeper
Tracy Booze handles financial operations with four years of accounting experience, leveraging software proficiency to streamline processes. She balances work with crafting hobbies and family time, contributing to the agency's operational efficiency.
Questions
What types of insurance does First Madison Insurance offer?
We provide auto, home, commercial, life, health, farm, and specialty insurance, including coverage for recreational vehicles and collector cars.
Do you offer after-hours appointments?
Yes, our team is available outside regular office hours by scheduling an appointment to accommodate your schedule.
Can I bind coverage through the website?
No, coverage requires direct contact with a licensed agent via phone to ensure accurate policy details and personalized service.
In which states do you provide insurance services?
We serve clients in South Dakota and seven additional states through partnerships with multiple insurance carriers.