Business Details
50+ Years
experience
Your Trusted Insurance Partner in Margaretville, NY
Sluiter Agency, Inc. has been a trusted name in insurance services since 1914, providing personalized solutions to individuals, families, and businesses across the Catskill Region and beyond. Our commitment to fair dealings and partnerships with reputable insurers ensures clients receive tailored coverage for property, casualty, life, and financial needs. With over a century of local expertise, we combine deep community roots with a dedication to evolving with the region's changing economic landscape. Our team of certified professionals brings decades of combined experience in insurance counseling, claims management, and financial planning.We pride ourselves on delivering award-winning service that prioritizes client relationships over transactions, ensuring peace of mind through comprehensive protection strategies. From auto and homeowners insurance to commercial policies and life coverage, our approach remains rooted in integrity and personalized attention. As a family-owned agency spanning three generations, we maintain the same dedication to excellence that earned us the Catskill Mountain News Readers Best Service Award ten times. Our understanding of local risks and opportunities allows us to craft solutions that truly meet our clients' unique needs.
Services
Auto Insurance
Homeowners Insurance
Commercial Insurance
Life Insurance
Workers Compensation
Recreational Vehicle Insurance
Umbrella Liability
Annuities
Disability Income Insurance
Details
- Year established: 1914
Highlights and features
- We have over 110 years of experience serving the Catskill Region's insurance needs
- Our team includes Certified Insurance Counselors and Certified Insurance Service Representatives
- We offer personalized service through both in-person and online channels
- We maintain partnerships with 20+ top-rated insurance carriers for optimal coverage options
- Our award-winning service has been recognized by the Catskill Mountain News for 10 consecutive years
What people say
Award winning personal service
Prompt attention to claims
Family owned and operated
Courteous and professional staff
One to one customer service
Services
Auto Insurance
Our auto insurance policies protect vehicles against damage, theft, and liability claims. We offer customizable coverage options including collision, comprehensive, and uninsured motorist protection. Our experienced agents help clients navigate policy selections to ensure adequate protection while maintaining competitive rates.
Homeowners Insurance
We provide comprehensive homeowners insurance covering property damage, personal liability, and additional living expenses. Our policies protect against common risks like fire, theft, and weather-related damage while offering customizable riders for valuable items and specific coverage needs.
Commercial Insurance
Our commercial insurance solutions protect businesses of all sizes with policies covering property damage, liability claims, workers compensation, and professional liability. We offer specialized coverage for business owners, equipment breakdowns, and inland marine risks to ensure comprehensive protection.
Life Insurance
We offer various life insurance products including term, whole, and universal life policies to provide financial security for beneficiaries. Our agents help clients determine appropriate coverage amounts and policy structures to meet long-term financial planning goals.
Workers Compensation
Our workers compensation insurance covers job-related injuries and illnesses, providing medical benefits and wage replacement. We help businesses comply with New York State Disability Benefits requirements while offering protection against workplace accident liabilities.
People
Matt Sluiter
President
President since 1995 with Certified Insurance Counselor designation. Specializes in financial services, business succession planning, and client relationship management. Graduated from St. Lawrence University and leads new sales initiatives.
Peter Sluiter
Director
Retired director with 40 years of insurance experience. Continues consulting on management issues and special projects. Instrumental in maintaining the agency's family legacy and operational excellence.
Ryan Sluiter
Vice President
Vice President since 2019 with licenses in property/casualty and life insurance. Focuses on commercial and personal insurance sales. Hartwick College graduate with expertise in new business development.
Wendy O'Reilly
Commercial Lines Customer Service Representative
Certified Insurance Counselor with 30+ years of experience. Manages claims department and commercial accounts. Provides notary services and ensures efficient policy administration for business clients.
Diana Campbell
Customer Service Representative
Licensed personal insurance broker with Certified Insurance Service Representative designation. Focuses on personalized coverage solutions and client education. Committed to understanding individual insurance needs.
Questions
What types of insurance does Sluiter Agency offer?
We offer auto, homeowners, commercial, life, workers compensation, recreational vehicle, umbrella liability, annuities, and disability income insurance policies.
How can I get an insurance quote?
Contact us at (845) 586-2641 or visit our office in Margaretville, NY to speak with an agent who will help determine your coverage needs.
Why choose Sluiter Agency for insurance?
We combine over 110 years of local experience with personalized service and access to multiple insurance carriers for comprehensive coverage options.
Do you serve businesses outside the Catskill Region?
While based in Margaretville, we serve clients throughout New York State and beyond with tailored commercial insurance solutions.
What makes your agency different from online insurers?
Our local agents provide personalized guidance, understand regional risks, and offer hands-on claims support that automated services cannot match.
