Call Now
Website
Call
Business Details
50+ Years
experience
Your Trusted Insurance Partner in Bluffton, Indiana
Archbold & Lewis Insurance has been serving families, individuals, and businesses in Northeast Indiana since 1936. As an independent agency, we prioritize personalized service by offering a choice of multiple insurance carriers tailored to each client's unique needs. Our team emphasizes community involvement, maintaining local relationships, and providing transparent communication to build trust.

With offices in Bluffton and Ossian, we combine decades of experience with a commitment to protecting clients through comprehensive insurance solutions. Our approach focuses on understanding clients as individuals, ensuring they receive optimal coverage at competitive rates while fostering long-term partnerships rooted in reliability and care.
Services
Auto Insurance Home Insurance Life Insurance Business Insurance Medicare Insurance Pet Insurance Flood Insurance RV Insurance ATV Insurance Wedding Insurance
Details
  • Year established: 1936
Highlights and features
  • We offer independent agent flexibility with access to multiple insurance carriers
  • Our team provides personalized service rooted in 85+ years of local experience
  • We prioritize transparent communication and community-focused relationships
  • Available to assist clients during claims with dedicated advocacy
  • Specialize in tailored coverage for unique needs like specialty vehicles and events
What people say
Personalized service Knowledgeable staff Community involvement Competitive rates Claims support
Services
Auto Insurance
We provide comprehensive auto insurance solutions for personal, commercial, motorcycle, and collector vehicles. Our policies protect against accidents, theft, and damage while offering competitive rates. With partnerships across multiple carriers, we help clients find coverage that matches their driving habits and budget needs.
Home Insurance
Our home insurance policies cover property damage from fire, theft, and natural disasters for homeowners, renters, and condo owners. We specialize in mobile home and farm insurance while providing guidance on policy details. Our team ensures clients understand their coverage limits and available endorsements.
Business Insurance
We offer tailored business insurance packages including property, liability, workers' compensation, and professional liability coverage. Our solutions protect small businesses, farms, and commercial vehicle operators while addressing industry-specific risks. We help clients navigate policy requirements and claims processes efficiently.
Life Insurance
We provide term, whole life, and return-of-premium insurance options to protect families financially. Our agents explain policy differences and help clients choose coverage amounts that align with their financial goals. We emphasize long-term planning and affordability across all life insurance products.
Specialty Insurance
Our specialty insurance includes coverage for boats, ATVs, RVs, pets, weddings, and identity theft protection. We address niche insurance needs with customized policies while explaining coverage specifics. Our team helps clients secure protection for non-traditional assets and events through specialized carriers.
People
Mike Lewis
President
Mike has led Archbold & Lewis Insurance since 1998, continuing his family's legacy in Bluffton. With over 25 years of experience, he combines community involvement as a fire captain with insurance expertise. He specializes in connecting with clients to understand their unique coverage needs.
Joe Lewis
Insurance Agent
A military veteran and part-time producer, Joe brings disciplined service to insurance sales. As Mike's nephew, he continues the family tradition while balancing seven children and sports coaching. His military background informs his approach to risk assessment and client protection.
Kari Lewis
Insurance Agent/CSR
Kari joined the team in 2023, combining family ties with insurance expertise. As Mike's niece, she brings a customer-first approach to policy sales and service. Her hospitality experience enhances her ability to connect with clients while managing complex insurance needs.
Amber McNally
Insurance Agent/CSR
Amber serves clients full-time while balancing military service in the Indiana Air National Guard. Her dual commitment to community service and insurance expertise helps clients navigate coverage options. She specializes in personalized customer service during policy purchases and claims.
Alyssa Brown
Insurance Agent/Notary
Alyssa provides comprehensive insurance solutions with expertise in all offered lines. Her background in motorsports and community involvement informs her understanding of specialty coverage needs. She actively participates in local organizations while maintaining technical insurance knowledge.
Questions
What areas do you serve?
We primarily serve Northeast Indiana communities including Bluffton, Fort Wayne, Huntington, and surrounding areas.
Do you offer specialty insurance?
Yes, we provide coverage for boats, ATVs, RVs, pets, weddings, and other unique insurance needs.
Are you available during claims?
Our team advocates for clients during claims and remains accessible to explain the process.
How do you find competitive rates?
As independent agents, we compare multiple carriers to find optimal coverage at competitive prices.
What insurance types do you offer?
We provide auto, home, life, business, Medicare, specialty, and commercial insurance solutions.
Are you locally owned?
Yes, we're a family-owned Bluffton agency serving the community since 1936.
Videos