Call Now
Website
Call
Business Details
Your Trusted Insurance Partner in Homer, NY
Benson Davis Insurance has been serving Central New York with personalized insurance solutions since our founding. We specialize in commercial, auto, and home insurance, offering competitive rates and comprehensive coverage tailored to individual needs. Our independent agency model allows us to represent multiple carriers, ensuring clients receive optimal policy matches. With a focus on local expertise and hands-on service, we provide flood, motorcycle, renters, and specialty insurance for both personal and business clients. Our team prioritizes direct client communication, maintaining accessibility through in-person visits, phone calls, and digital channels.

We streamline the quoting process with free, no-obligation consultations available online or at our Homer office. Backed by partnerships with leading insurers like Erie Insurance and Progressive, we deliver customized risk management strategies. Our commitment to community extends through educational resources and transparent policy explanations. For over two decades, we've built trust through consistent claims support and policyholder advocacy. This combination of local knowledge and national carrier strength positions us as a reliable insurance partner for families and businesses alike.
Services
Commercial Insurance Auto Insurance Home Insurance Flood Insurance Motorcycle Insurance Renters Insurance General Liability Workers Compensation Property Insurance Farm Insurance
Highlights and features
  • We offer competitive rates across multiple insurance categories
  • We provide comprehensive coverage options for personal and business needs
  • Our independent agency model ensures unbiased policy recommendations
  • We maintain direct client communication channels for personalized service
  • We streamline insurance processes with free, no-obligation quote options
Services
Commercial Insurance
We provide comprehensive commercial insurance solutions protecting businesses against liability claims, property damage, and operational risks. Our offerings include general liability, workers compensation, and commercial auto policies tailored to specific industry needs. With access to multiple carriers, we help businesses in Central New York secure cost-effective coverage that meets regulatory requirements while safeguarding assets.
Auto Insurance
Our auto insurance policies protect personal and commercial vehicles against accidents, theft, and weather-related damage. We offer competitive rates for standard auto coverage as well as specialty policies for motorcycles, RVs, and classic cars. As an independent agency, we compare multiple providers to find coverage that balances protection and affordability for drivers in Homer and surrounding areas.
Home Insurance
We offer residential insurance solutions covering homes against fire, weather events, and liability claims. Our policies include standard homeowners coverage, flood insurance for high-risk areas, and umbrella policies for additional protection. By representing multiple insurers, we help homeowners in Central New York find customized solutions that protect their property while meeting budgetary constraints.
Flood Insurance
We specialize in flood insurance policies for properties in high-risk areas, providing coverage beyond standard homeowners policies. Our flood insurance options protect against water damage from heavy rains, overflowing rivers, and other natural causes. We work with national flood insurance programs and private carriers to offer competitive rates for residential and commercial properties in flood-prone regions of New York State.
Workers Compensation
We provide workers compensation insurance meeting New York State requirements for businesses with employees. This coverage protects employers against costs associated with work-related injuries or illnesses. Our policies cover medical expenses, lost wages, and legal fees while helping businesses implement safety protocols to reduce workplace risks across various industries in Central New York.
Questions
How can I get a free insurance quote?
Contact us via phone, email, or our online form to receive a free, no-obligation insurance quote tailored to your needs.
What insurance types do you offer?
We provide auto, home, flood, commercial, workers compensation, and specialty insurance for boats, RVs, and farms across Central New York.
Can you help with business insurance needs?
Yes, we offer comprehensive commercial insurance solutions including liability coverage, property insurance, and workers compensation policies for businesses of all sizes.
How do claims get processed?
File claims directly through our office where we'll connect you with the appropriate carrier and assist throughout the resolution process.
Do you serve areas beyond Homer?
We serve all of Central New York including Cortland, Onondaga, and surrounding counties with personalized insurance solutions.