Business Details
43 Years
experience
Emergency
services
Your Trusted Insurance Partner for Auto, Home & Business Coverage
Polly Insurance is a pioneering insurance marketplace dedicated to simplifying the process of acquiring auto, home, life, and business insurance while delivering exceptional value. Founded in 1983 as a commercial agency, we have evolved into a tech-driven platform trusted by millions, partnering with over 40 leading insurance carriers to provide competitive quotes and comprehensive coverage. Our mission is to make insurance inherently simple, transparent, and customer-centric, guided by core values of authenticity, curiosity, boldness, and trust. With decades of combined experience in insurance and automotive industries, our team of experts has insured $11 billion in assets and generated 5 million quotes, ensuring clients receive tailored solutions that meet their unique needs. We prioritize innovation, having pioneered embedded insurance solutions for car dealerships, and remain committed to transforming the industry through digital retailing and data-driven strategies.Our customer-first approach emphasizes ease of use, significant savings (averaging $1,001 annually on auto insurance), and 24/7 support, earning us recognition as a four-time Agent of the Year award winner. We operate with unwavering integrity, offering bundling discounts, telematics-based savings, and specialized coverage options for homeowners, renters, and businesses. Our leadership team, comprising seasoned professionals from Cox Automotive, Dealertrack, and other industry leaders, drives our vision of redefining insurance experiences. With offices in Madison, WI, and a nationwide network, we serve clients across the U.S., combining local expertise with global technological advancements to deliver reliable, affordable protection.
Services
Auto Insurance
Home Insurance
Life Insurance
Business Insurance
Bundled Policies
Details
- Year established: 1983
Highlights and features
- We offer 40+ trusted insurance carrier options for competitive rates.
- Our platform saves customers an average of $1,001 annually on auto insurance.
- We provide embedded insurance solutions for car dealerships nationwide.
- Our team includes industry veterans with decades of insurance expertise.
- We guarantee 24/7 customer support and personalized policy guidance.
What people say
Cut insurance costs in half
Quickest way to save
Never dissatisfied after 9 years
Saved nearly half with same coverage
Most helpful insurance experience
Services
Auto Insurance
Polly offers comprehensive auto insurance solutions through a network of 40+ carriers, covering liability, collision, and comprehensive needs. Customers save an average of $1,001 annually, with options for telematics-based discounts, low-mileage reductions, and bundling with home or life policies. Our platform simplifies claims processing, providing rental car reimbursement and rapid replacement vehicles in emergencies.
Home Insurance
We provide homeowners and renters insurance with coverage for dwelling, personal property, liability, and additional living expenses. Bundling with auto insurance yields up to 10% savings. Policies include protection against natural disasters, theft, and liability claims, with discounts for security systems, new construction, and claims-free histories.
Life Insurance
Polly partners with TruStage to offer term and whole life insurance up to $300,000 without medical exams. Term policies provide affordable coverage for specific periods, while whole life includes cash value components. Rated 'A' by AM Best, these policies protect families financially with flexible premiums and instant online quotes.
Business Insurance
Our business insurance solutions include BOPs, cyber liability, workers' compensation, and commercial auto policies. Trusted by 5,000+ businesses since 1983, we offer tailored protection for property damage, liability claims, and operational continuity, with 96% client retention and partnerships with major commercial carriers.
Bundled Policies
Combining auto, home, life, or business insurance through Polly unlocks significant discounts, including up to 10% savings on bundled home/auto policies. This approach simplifies management while providing comprehensive protection across multiple asset classes, with personalized quotes and integrated claims support.
People
Rick Gibbs
CEO
Rick Gibbs is a seasoned entrepreneur and former co-founder of Dealer.com. With leadership roles at Dealertrack and Cox Automotive, he brings 25+ years of digital marketing and product strategy expertise to Polly's innovative insurance platform.
Travis Fitzgerald
Chief Strategy Officer, Co-Founder
Travis Fitzgerald, a dealership owner and former insurance agency operator, leverages deep automotive and P&C insurance expertise to drive Polly's strategic partnerships and market expansion as co-founder and CRO.
Jeffrey Mongeon
Chief Revenue Officer, Co-Founder
Jeffrey Mongeon co-founded Polly after a decade in insurance underwriting and data science. He oversees sales and carrier relations, utilizing his experience in tech-enabled marketplace distribution to lead Polly's growth.
Kristin Halpin Perry
Chief People Officer
Kristin Halpin Perry leads HR with 25+ years of global executive experience. Founder of Veraz Consulting, she specializes in organizational development and talent strategy, holding multiple business and coaching certifications.
Kurt Liebegott
Chief Financial Officer
Kurt Liebegott manages Polly's finances with 25+ years in accounting and operations. A licensed CPA, he previously held CFO roles at Sharecare and other firms, blending entrepreneurial agility with Fortune 500 financial expertise.
Questions
Is Polly an insurance company?
Polly is an insurance marketplace partnering with 40+ carriers to compare quotes and find optimal coverage, not an insurer itself.
How does Polly help save on insurance?
We compare quotes from multiple carriers in one platform, leveraging partnerships to secure competitive rates and bundling discounts.
Why receive emails from Polly after dealership visits?
Polly powers insurance solutions at dealerships; follow-ups help complete quotes and secure coverage through trusted carrier networks.
What insurance types does Polly offer?
We provide auto, home, life, business insurance, and bundled policies through our network of top-rated carriers.
Are there discounts for bundling policies?
Yes, bundling auto and home insurance saves up to 10%, with additional savings for multi-vehicle households and loyal customers.
How to file a claim with Polly?
Contact your insurance company directly or reach out to Polly's service team for assistance during business hours.
