Protecting Your Future, One Policy at a Time
At Gettelfinger Insurance, we are dedicated to providing our clients with personalized service and tailored insurance solutions. As a third-generation, family-owned and operated insurance agency, we have a long-standing commitment to delivering exceptional support to our customers. Our team of knowledgeable agents is passionate about finding the perfect insurance policy for each unique individual, business, or family.
Our History
Gettelfinger Insurance was founded in 1929 by Henry Gettelfinger, who began his insurance career as a farmer in Bradford, Indiana. Henry's entrepreneurial spirit and dedication to providing excellent service have been passed down through the generations, shaping our agency into what it is today. From humble beginnings to where we are now, our commitment to serving our clients with integrity and expertise remains unwavering.
Why Choose Our Agency?
At Gettelfinger Insurance, we pride ourselves on being:
- Independent: We are not tied to any one insurance company, allowing us to shop around for the best deals and policies for our clients.
- Locally owned and operated: We are deeply rooted in the Southern Indiana and Kentucky communities, giving us a deeper understanding of the unique needs of our customers.
- Third-generation company: Our family's legacy in the insurance industry has given us the knowledge and expertise to provide the highest-quality service and solutions.
- Certified Insurance Counselors: We have a team of certified professionals who are dedicated to educating our clients on their insurance options and ensuring they receive the best possible coverage.
Our Services
At Gettelfinger Insurance, we offer a wide range of insurance products and services, including:
- Auto Insurance: We provide coverage for preferred auto, high-risk auto, and classic auto insurance policies, along with discounts for multi-car and combined insurance policies.
- Business Insurance: We help businesses of all sizes and industries find the right insurance coverage for their unique needs, including liability, commercial property, and workers' compensation insurance.
- Home Insurance: We offer coverage for homes, farms, and farms, providing protection against unforeseen events and disasters.
- Life Insurance: We provide a range of life insurance options to help protect your loved ones and ensure a secure financial future.
Contact Us
At Gettelfinger Insurance, we are committed to providing personalized attention to each and every client. Whether you're looking for auto insurance, business insurance, or life insurance, we are here to help. Please do not hesitate to contact us to discuss your insurance needs and how we can help you achieve peace of mind.
Positive Reviews
The reviewers praise Dean Gettelfinger and Gettelfinger Insurance for their excellent service, professionalism, and honesty. They highlight his responsiveness, helpfulness, and ability to make them feel valued as customers. Many reviewers have been clients for a long time and appreciate the personalized attention and guidance they receive.
Areas of Excellence
Some common themes that emerge from the positive reviews include:
- Candor and Honesty: Dean is praised for being truthful and transparent in his dealings with clients, which helps to build trust and confidence.
- Responsive and Helpful: Reviewers appreciate how quickly and thoroughly Dean responds to their questions and concerns.
- Personal and Knowledgeable: Dean and his team are described as being very personable, knowledgeable, and patient in their approach to insurance planning and problem-solving.
- Long-term Relationships: Many reviewers have been clients for a long time and appreciate the long-term relationships they have built with Dean and his team.
Negative Review
One reviewer, Swifts Stuff, had a negative experience with Gettelfinger Insurance, complaining that they don't like to answer the phone and charge "an arm and a leg".

Be the first to review Gettelfinger Insurance.
Write a Review