We strive to do the right thing for you and your insurance
Carey Insurance is an independent insurance agency dedicated to helping our clients find the right coverage at the right price. We are located in Warminster, PA, and serve clients in Pennsylvania, Maryland, and New Jersey. As an independent agency, we work with several top-rated insurance carriers to bring you the coverage you deserve. We do all the insurance shopping for you so that you don't have to lift a finger.
Our Services
At Carey Insurance, we provide a variety of personal insurance and business insurance solutions.
- Personal Insurance: We offer trusted advice and insurance solutions to protect what matters most. Our personal insurance solutions include auto insurance, home insurance, individual life insurance, renters insurance, and umbrella insurance.
- Business Insurance: Our business insurance solutions include coverage and risk management solutions for companies of all sizes. Our business insurance solutions include business owners insurance, business auto insurance, workers' compensation insurance, commercial umbrella insurance, and key person life insurance.
Meet Our Team
Our team of experienced agents prides themselves on knowing their clients personally. We build a relationship with you to understand your unique risks and build an insurance plan that's right for you. We are here to help you find the right coverage and to provide excellent customer service.
Why Choose Carey Insurance?
At Carey Insurance, we strive to do the right thing for you and your insurance. We are committed to providing you with the best insurance solutions and excellent customer service. Here are some reasons why you should choose Carey Insurance:
- Independent Agency: As an independent agency, we represent multiple insurance companies, giving you more options and better coverage.
- Licensed Insurance Advisors: Our agents are licensed insurance advisors who can guide you through the insurance process.
- Personalized Service: We build a relationship with you to understand your unique risks and build an insurance plan that's right for you.
- Wide Variety of Insurance Solutions: We offer a wide variety of insurance solutions to meet your needs.
- By Your Side Every Step of the Way: We are there for you every step of the way, from finding the right coverage to filing a claim.
What Makes Us Different?
At Carey Insurance, we are a Trusted Choice agency, meaning we are committed to providing you with the best insurance solutions. We strive to uphold Erie Insurance's long-standing commitment to service. We are there for you in your time of need and offer a wide variety of insurance solutions. We are a reputable company that has your best interests in mind.
Our Clients Rave About Us
Don't just take our word for it. Check out our reviews and see why our clients love us. We have real clients with real reviews and real coverage. Our clients rave about our excellent service, trusted advice, and the value we provide. We are committed to providing you with the best insurance solutions and excellent customer service.
Exceptional Customer Service and Competitive Rates
It's clear that Carey Insurance and their agents, such as Donna Spatz and Ed, have set themselves apart from other insurance companies with their top-notch customer service and competitive rates. Multiple reviewers have praised their agents' attentiveness, knowledge, and professionalism, citing instances where they went above and beyond to find the best coverage options for their clients. Even reviewers who were initially skeptical or had issues found that the company's staff were responsive and helpful in resolving their concerns.
Knowledgeable and Supportive Agents
The agents at Carey Insurance have received rave reviews for their expertise and helpfulness. Many reviewers have noted that their agents took the time to explain policies and coverage options in a clear and concise manner, making the process of selecting an insurance plan easy and stress-free. Some reviewers have even praised their agents for their ability to navigate complex situations, such as finding coverage for unusual or high-risk situations.
Competitive Rates and Helpful staff
Reviewers have also been impressed with the company's competitive rates and the staff's willingness to shop around to find the best deals. Many have reported significant savings compared to their previous insurance policies, and some have even received discounts for their specific circumstances. The company's agents have also been praised for their ability to procure special coverage for unique situations, such as high-value vehicles or unusual insurance needs.
The one negative review
One reviewer had a negative experience with the company, citing poor customer service and a lack of transparency. They mentioned that their demeanor shifted when they asked about switching to a cheaper policy, leading them to feel like the company prioritized profits over customers. However, this reviewer's experience appears to be an outlier, as the vast majority of reviewers have had positive interactions with Carey Insurance and its agents.

Be the first to review Carey Insurance.
Write a Review