Business Details
41 Years
experience
Your Trusted Insurance Partner in Cape Girardeau
Founded in 1985, Coalter Insurance Group has built a legacy of personalized service and community commitment. Our journey began with Ted R. Coalter's passion for insurance, evolving into a full-service brokerage with multiple carriers. We prioritize finding tailored solutions for home, auto, business, life, and employee benefits coverage, emphasizing transparency and eliminating industry red tape. With over 40 years of combined experience, our team serves as strategic advisors, guiding clients through policy selection and claims processes.We differentiate ourselves through continuous support, competitive pricing research, and a dedication to local community initiatives. Our mission remains focused on simplifying insurance complexities while maintaining a client-centric approach that values trust and long-term partnerships.
Services
Home Insurance
Auto Insurance
Business Insurance
Employee Benefits
Life Insurance
Details
- Year established: 1985
Highlights and features
- 40+ years of combined insurance expertise with multiple carrier partnerships
- Personalized service eliminating insurance industry red tape
- Community-focused agency with local involvement since 1985
- Dedicated support through policy selection and claims processes
- Competitive pricing research for optimal coverage-value balance
What people say
Personalized service
Knowledgeable staff
Community focus
Cost-effective solutions
Responsive support
Services
Home Insurance
Protect your home and personal property with customized insurance solutions. We offer comprehensive coverage options for residential properties, including protection against common risks like fire, theft, and natural disasters. Our team helps clients navigate policy details to ensure adequate protection while maintaining cost-effectiveness.
Auto Insurance
Comprehensive auto insurance coverage for personal and commercial vehicles. Our policies include liability protection, collision coverage, and additional options for specialized vehicles like motorcycles and campers. We work with multiple carriers to find competitive rates while maintaining essential coverage for drivers across Missouri.
Business Insurance
Tailored insurance solutions for businesses of all sizes. Our offerings include general liability, workers' compensation, commercial auto, and business owners policies. We specialize in creating comprehensive protection plans that address specific industry risks while helping businesses maintain compliance and financial security.
Employee Benefits
Group insurance solutions to attract and retain talent. We provide health, dental, vision, disability, and life insurance options for businesses, including access to the Missouri Chamber Benefit Plan. Our team helps employers navigate complex benefit structures to find cost-effective solutions that meet employees' needs.
Life Insurance
Protect your family's future with customized life insurance policies. We offer term and permanent life insurance options that provide financial security for loved ones, business protection, and potential tax-advantaged savings. Our advisors help clients understand policy features to select appropriate coverage amounts and types.
People
Ted R. Coalter
Founder
Established the agency in 1985 after discovering his passion for insurance while attending SEMO. Built the business on principles of integrity, personalized service, and community commitment.
Laura Coalter Parker
Insurance Consultant, Partner
Brings extensive industry knowledge and client-focused approach to help individuals and businesses navigate insurance options. Committed to finding optimal coverage solutions for clients.
Debbie Coalter
Group Benefits Advisor, Partner
Specializes in employee benefits solutions, helping businesses create competitive benefit packages. Focuses on simplifying complex insurance structures for employer and employee satisfaction.
Brandi Bass
Consultant
Provides personalized insurance guidance with attention to individual client needs. Combines technical expertise with approachable service to help clients understand their coverage options.
Bailey Blair
Client Services
Supports clients throughout their insurance journey, from policy selection to claims assistance. Focuses on delivering responsive, transparent service while maintaining attention to policy details.
Questions
How do I choose the right insurance coverage?
We help clients evaluate their specific needs through detailed consultations, considering factors like property value, business risks, family size, and financial goals.
What areas do you serve?
We primarily serve Cape Girardeau, Jackson, and Sikeston, Missouri, with insurance solutions tailored to local needs and regulations.
Can you help with business insurance requirements?
Yes, we provide comprehensive commercial insurance packages including liability coverage, workers' compensation, and industry-specific protections for Missouri businesses.
How do claims work with your agency?
We guide clients through the entire claims process, providing support with documentation submission and acting as an advocate during claim resolution.
Do you offer group benefits for small businesses?
Yes, we offer access to the Missouri Chamber Benefit Plan and other group insurance options designed for small businesses' unique needs.
What sets you apart from other insurers?
Our local ownership, multi-carrier options, and personalized approach differentiate us from larger agencies that take a hands-off approach.
Videos
