Your Local Independent Insurance Agent
At Hometown Atlantic Insurance, we pride ourselves on being a local, independent insurance agency based in Long Beach, New York. Since our founding in 1999, we have been dedicated to providing our clients with personalized insurance solutions that fit their unique needs and budget. Our experienced team of insurance professionals is committed to providing exceptional customer service, tailored policy coverage, and competitive rates.
Our Story
Founded by Tracey Brennan, a marketing graduate from Quinnipiac University, Hometown Atlantic Insurance began as a small operation in an apartment in Tracey's home. Since then, we have grown steadily, expanding our services to include a team of licensed brokers and a wide range of insurance products. We have a long history of serving the community, and we take pride in being a trusted and reputable insurance partner.
Our Team
Our team of licensed brokers is dedicated to providing exceptional service and tailored insurance solutions. Our brokers are highly trained and experienced in the insurance industry, ensuring that our clients receive the best coverage options at the most competitive rates. Meet our team:
- Grayson Donnellan, a graduate of Johnson & Wales University, focuses on day-to-day operations, quoting new and existing clients, and customer service matters.
- Alexandra Howley, a graduate of Hofstra University and John Jay College, specializes in recruiting new business, bookkeeping, and internet marketing strategies.
Our Services
At Hometown Atlantic Insurance, we offer a comprehensive range of insurance products and services, including:
- Property & Casualty Insurance: We provide competitive rates on home, auto, and umbrella insurance policies for individuals and families.
- Business Insurance: Our experienced team helps small businesses and entrepreneurs find the right insurance coverage for their unique needs.
- Flood Insurance: As coastal residents, we specialize in flood insurance policies and can help clients navigate the FEMA requirements.
- Defense Driving Course: We offer a defensive driving course to help clients reduce their insurance rates and stay safe on the roads.
Why Choose Us
At Hometown Atlantic Insurance, we strive to stand out from the rest by providing exceptional customer service, tailored policy coverage, and competitive rates. Our commitment to our clients has earned us a reputation for excellence and loyalty. We take the time to understand our clients' unique needs and tailor our services to meet their specific requirements.
Get Started
Whether you're seeking an insurance policy, considering a change, or simply looking for expert advice, we invite you to contact us for a free insurance quote. Our experienced team is here to help you navigate the complex world of insurance and find the best coverage options for your needs and budget. Contact us today to schedule an appointment and take the first step towards securing your future.
Exceptional Customer Service
The reviewers are extremely satisfied with the level of customer service provided by Hometown Atlantic. They praise the staff for being helpful, available, and responsive to their needs. The staff is commended for going above and beyond to ensure clients' satisfaction.
Insurance Expertise
Hometown Atlantic is credited with providing expert advice and guidance, particularly in terms of saving money on insurance policies. The reviewers appreciate the personalized approach taken by the staff, who take the time to explain the claims process and offer valuable recommendations.
Efficient and Seamless Experience
The reviewers have had a seamless experience when switching policies or filing claims. The staff is efficient and effective in handling these processes, making it worry-free for clients.
Personal Touch
The reviewers appreciate the small office setting, which allows for a more personalized approach to client relationships. The staff is knowledgeable and always available to answer questions and address concerns.

Be the first to review Hometown Atlantic.
Write a Review