Our History
At Amstutz Insurance, Inc., we take pride in our rich history, dating back to 1939 when our founder, Dale Amstutz, established our first office. Over the years, we have grown and expanded to become one of the premier insurance agencies in Indiana, Michigan, Ohio, and Florida. Our commitment to excellence and customer satisfaction has been the cornerstone of our success.
Our Services
As an independent insurance agency, we represent multiple top-rated insurance companies, enabling us to offer a wide range of services to our clients. Our services include:
Personal Lines
- Home Insurance
- Auto Insurance
- Life Insurance
- Recreational Vehicles Insurance
- Senior Benefits
Commercial Lines
- Business Insurance
- Farm & Ranch Insurance
- Business Liability Insurance
- Cyber Threat Insurance
Our Team
At Amstutz Insurance, we pride ourselves on our experienced and dedicated team of professionals. With a combined 350 years of insurance experience, our agents are knowledgeable and committed to helping you find the right insurance coverage for your needs.
Meet Our Team
- John Amstutz, CPCU, CIC - Agent and Owner
- Vera Neuenschwander - Agent, Personal Lines
- Carol Woehnker - Agent, Commercial Lines
- Michelle Bassett - Agent, Personal Lines
- Matthew E. Roberts, CLCS - Agent, Commercial Lines
- Tammy Weller - Agent, Personal Lines
Our Commitment
At Amstutz Insurance, we are committed to providing exceptional customer service, quick claims response, and competitive rates. Whether you're a homeowner, business owner, or individual seeking insurance, we will work with you to create a personalized insurance plan tailored to your specific needs.
Get a Quote
If you're in need of insurance in Indiana, Michigan, Ohio, or Florida, get a free quote today! Contact us at one of our four convenient locations:
- Fort Wayne Office - Northeast: 260-493-3444
- Fort Wayne Office - Southwest: 260-432-8736
- Ossian Office: 260-622-4169
- Auburn Office: 260-333-7770
Overall Satisfaction
The insurance agency has received rave reviews from multiple customers. The reviewers have praised the agency's insurance agent, Ron, or actually Amstutz, for their excellent service, fast responses, and friendly demeanor.
Communication
The reviewers have mentioned that they can easily contact the agency with concerns or questions regarding their policies, and receive prompt responses. Jessie Adam has stated that Ron is readily available to address any issues, while Charlie Chapman has appreciated the agency's responsiveness with policy work and claims.
Quality of Service
The reviewers have expressed their satisfaction with the agency's service, describing it as "excellent", "fast and friendly", and even "5+ star". Kevin Shafer has further emphasized that the agency has provided great service for many years, although he wishes they could service his new home state.
Conclusion
In conclusion, the insurance agency has impressed its customers with its exceptional service, quick responses, and friendly staff. The reviewers have praised the agency's ability to address concerns and questions promptly, making them a top choice for insurance coverage.

Be the first to review Amstutz Insurance.
Write a Review