Business Details
50+ Years
experience
Your Trusted Independent Insurance Partner in Central Pennsylvania
First Affiliated Insurance has been dedicated to meeting client insurance needs since 1974, offering personalized solutions across Central Pennsylvania. Our agency prioritizes client-centric service, combining decades of industry expertise with partnerships with top-rated national and regional carriers. We maintain two convenient locations in State College and Millheim, serving individuals and businesses through comprehensive risk assessment and tailored coverage strategies.Our team of experienced advisors conducts annual account reviews to ensure optimal coverage alignment with evolving client needs. We distinguish ourselves through a concierge-style client experience, emphasizing transparency, choice, and proactive risk management for both personal and commercial insurance portfolios.
Services
Personal Insurance
Business Insurance
Life Insurance
Auto Insurance
Home Insurance
Commercial Umbrella
Cyber Liability
Workers Compensation
Property Insurance
Risk Management
Details
- Year established: 1974
Highlights and features
- We offer over 50 years of localized insurance expertise since 1974
- Our team provides annual account reviews for coverage optimization
- We maintain partnerships with top-rated national and regional carriers
- We deliver concierge-style client service with personalized attention
- Our advisors specialize in both personal and commercial risk management
Services
Personal Insurance
We provide customized personal insurance solutions protecting individuals' assets and lifestyles. Our advisors assess unique risks to create comprehensive coverage plans that adapt to life changes. Clients benefit from access to multiple carriers and specialized policies for homes, vehicles, and valuable possessions.
Business Insurance
Our business insurance services address commercial risks through tailored coverage packages. We evaluate operational exposures to develop cost-effective solutions that protect against property damage, liability claims, and business interruption. Specialized policies cater to industry-specific needs across various sectors in Central Pennsylvania.
Risk Management
We implement proactive risk management strategies to identify and mitigate potential threats. Our approach combines industry expertise with personalized analysis to develop comprehensive protection plans. This service helps both individuals and businesses maintain financial security through strategic risk avoidance and transfer mechanisms.
Commercial Umbrella
Our commercial umbrella policies provide additional liability protection beyond standard coverage limits. This service safeguards businesses from catastrophic losses through supplemental policies that activate when primary insurance reaches its limits. We help clients determine appropriate coverage levels based on specific risk profiles.
Cyber Liability
We offer cyber liability insurance solutions protecting businesses from data breach financial impacts. Our advisors help clients assess digital risks and implement coverage for breach response, legal defense, and regulatory fines. This service addresses evolving cybersecurity threats across various industry sectors.
People
Robert Matheney
Co-Owner
With decades of experience in the insurance industry, Robert Matheney leads First Affiliated Insurance as Co-Owner, bringing extensive knowledge of risk management and client service to the agency.
Kevin Johnson
Co-Owner
Kevin Johnson, as Co-Owner, contributes specialized insurance expertise and leadership to First Affiliated Insurance, maintaining the agency's commitment to personalized client service and comprehensive coverage solutions.
Melanie S. Eger
Office Manager
Melanie S. Eger oversees office operations at First Affiliated Insurance, ensuring efficient service delivery and client support through her extensive administrative and insurance industry experience.
Monica Cingle
Commercial Accounts
Monica Cingle specializes in commercial insurance solutions, leveraging her industry knowledge to develop tailored protection strategies for businesses across various sectors in Central Pennsylvania.
Kevin Veal
Owner
Kevin Veal serves as Owner of Fetzer Insurance, extending First Affiliated Insurance's service capabilities through his expertise in insurance solutions and client relationship management.
Questions
What types of insurance do you offer?
We provide personal and commercial insurance including auto, home, life, business owners policies, cyber liability, and specialized coverage for unique risks.
How do you help clients save money on insurance?
Through annual policy reviews, carrier comparisons, and risk assessment strategies that identify coverage gaps and potential cost savings while maintaining adequate protection.
Do you serve businesses outside State College?
Yes, we serve businesses throughout Central Pennsylvania including Centre, Clinton, Clearfield, Lycoming, Berks, Dauphin, and Bucks counties.
How does your concierge client service work?
We provide personalized attention with dedicated advisors who guide clients through policy selection, claims processing, and ongoing coverage adjustments to meet evolving needs.
What sets you apart from other insurance agencies?
Our combination of local expertise since 1974, access to multiple top-rated carriers, and commitment to annual coverage reviews for optimal protection distinguishes our service approach.
