Founded on a strong Pioneer Tradition, Belle Prairie Mutual Insurance Company has been protecting the property of thousands of customers throughout Central Illinois for over 140 years. As a small, private insurance company, we offer our clients personalized attention and individualized services that are second-to-none. We understand the unique needs of rural, farming, and small-town families, making your experience with us easy.
Our History
On December 20, 1873, a group of men met in Cropsey, Illinois to discuss the possibility of forming a company that would provide protection to their properties in case of fire or lightning damage. As these were great concerns during the late 1800s, the men felt a strong desire to procure this type of protection and offer it to other farmers and landowners in the area. On April 3, 1874, under an Act by the General Assembly, the company was allowed to incorporate and began operating under the name Belle Prairie Farmers Township Mutual Fire Insurance Company. With no capital, the company began writing policies in five townships in McLean and Livingston Counties, the first of which was issued on April 4, 1874.
Our Products
At Belle Prairie Mutual Insurance Company, we provide a range of products and protections to suit your needs. Our policies are designed to protect your property, personal belongings, and financial stability. Below, please find more information about our products:
Home-Guard
Protect your home with our all-inclusive Home-Guard policy. This package provides both property and liability coverages for owner-occupied city or town dwellings. Our policy will protect your home and personal property, as well as protect you from financial disaster that may arise from accidents or injuries occurring on your property.
FarMate
FarMate provides protection for property on the entire farm, including various options to fit any farming operation. Our policy protects your dwelling, personal property, farm service buildings, and farm personal property (machinery, livestock, grain, etc.).
Farm-Guard
Whether you are a farm owner or tenant, Farm-Guard provides complete liability coverage. Our policy is designed to protect your farm and personal belongings from financial disaster.
Other Products
We also offer Rented Dwelling Policy, Tenant Policy, and Unit Owners Policy, which provide additional protection for your property and personal belongings.
Why Choose Us
At Belle Prairie Mutual Insurance Company, we believe in providing personalized and individualized service from people you know and trust. Our team of qualified agents and representatives are committed to providing timely and efficient service to all of our customers. When you work with us, you can be confident that you are working with a locally-based company that has a deep understanding of the unique needs of rural, farming, and small-town families.
Contact Us Today
If you are looking for a trusted insurance partner that can provide personalized and timely service, contact us today to learn more about our products and protections. Our team is committed to helping you find the right protection for your property and personal belongings.
Claims and Customer Service
Belle Prairie Insurance received praise for their prompt and professional handling of claims. Many reviewers appreciated the quick response time, thorough assessments, and timely payment of claims. The new manager and adjusters, such as TJ Welte, were particularly commended for their friendly and helpful attitude.
Positivity towards Independent Agents and Pricing
Some reviewers had positive experiences with independent agents, finding the process simple and efficient. Additionally, several reviewers mentioned that Belle Prairie's pricing was competitive and reasonable.
Long-Term Satisfaction
Long-term customers expressed satisfaction with the company, citing fair and honest dealings, reasonable premiums, and swift claims handling over the years.
Negative Experiences with Claims and Customer Service
However, some reviewers had negative experiences with claims handling, citing low estimates, denied claims, and poor communication. Adjusters, such as Lonnie Rothery, were criticized for being difficult to work with, and some reviewers felt that the company did not provide adequate information or follow-up.
Frustrations with Delays and Lack of Transparency
Several reviewers expressed frustration with the lengthy claims process, lack of transparency, and unresponsive customer service. Some felt that the company did not care about their situation, and that claims were not handled fairly or efficiently.
Be the first to review Bell Prairie Mutual Insurance.
Write a Review
